Beds in the Orchard started out as a small campaign to stand up for the women of North Lancashire after all the inpatient beds in the The Orchard psychiatric unit were closed to women and it became a male only ward.
We have documented all the way through our blog about why this is so harmful to the women of our area and why, even though the Trust has now said it's temporary, it should never have happened in the first place.
We were thrilled when our cause was taken up by the brilliant folks at BBC Radio Lancashire, but it seems that our issue has touched a more national nerve and today our campaign has been publicised in The New Statesman.
http://www.newstatesman.com/health/2014/11/orchard-psychiatric-ward-closure-women-bear-cost-unchecked-male-dominance
Everyone at Beds In the Orchard would like to pass on their grateful thanks to everyone who has supported us. The women of North Lancashire deserve to be heard. A special thanks to Tim Padfield and Graham Liver at BBC Radio Lancashire and Glosswitch at The New Statesman for making our voice a loud one.
Thursday, 6 November 2014
Is the decision to close the Unit to women vulnerable to a judicial review?
One of our supporters thinks this may be the case, as they raise it in a letter to Heather Tierney-Moore, Chief Exec of Lancashire Care NHS Trust. The full letter is below.
Ms Heather Tierney-Moore, Chief Executive,
Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust,
Sceptre Point,
Sceptre Way, Walton Summit,
Preston,
PR5 6AW
Dear Ms Tierney-Moore
Re The Orchard Unit
I do not make a habit of writing to complete strangers at the
other end of the country to complain, but I am writing at the
prompting of my sister. She has been a patient on several occasions
in the old Ridge Lea Hospital and may well need a bed in the future.
As I understand it, the new Orchard Unit has been made exclusively
male suddenly and without consulting with the public or service
users. If so, I would note that this decision is of dubious legality
and may be vulnerable to judicial review.
The account given is that there is a pressing need for beds for
male patients and women are being excluded on the grounds that they
are vulnerable to the male patients in such an environment. If this
is so then I believe that the decision is entirely the wrong way
round; the vulnerable patients need to be protected and if, in an
extreme case, the men (in general) are liable to prey on women then
it is the issue of the male patients that needs to be addressed. To
exclude women is to punish the vulnerable, surely?
There is clearly a need for more beds for the mentally ill in the
Preston Area as there is such competition for the beds and maybe the
closure of Ridge Lea should have been preceded by an analysis of
future needs and the level of peak demand (NOT average demand, as
this will always fall well short of actual need). I can appreciate
that in an era of budget pressures (and when were there not such
pressures?) providing beds is always difficult, but I believe the
recent political statements reveal by the targets being introduced
for mental health treatment, there is more political will to improve
mental health treatment than for many years. It surely ill behoves a
chief executive to follow a policy that seemingly reduces the
capacity let alone the quality of care. I believe it may well be that
The Orchard Unit needs a companion unit for female patients and
probably larger and preferably in advance of provision for male
patients.
I worked as a chief officer in the Probation Service for many
years. My experience is that men do not present with as many mental
health issues as women but they have almost an exclusive hold on
severe personality disorders. If the rise in male patient numbers is
in any way a reflection of this I would strongly suggest that they
are not amenable to treatment, that they will remain in your care for
as long as they can manage it to avoid the courts/prisons and will
likely pose a major threat to staff, other patients and themselves.
It is not sensible, in my view, to have such people in contact with
the generally mentally ill, and especially if those mentally ill
people are in any way vulnerable (which they surely would be) and
women.
I look forward to your comments.
Temporary or not, this is a closure that should never have happened
We do wonder whether Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust is feeling more secure now.
They have told us publicly that it’s a temporary move that won’t last for weeks and weeks. That it’s to cope with a peak in demand for male beds, that of course has nothing to do with them closing 15 of them elsewhere in the county. And they’ve publicly stated that it’s not having a negative impact despite the women telling them that it is.
In their eyes this is surely a non-story now. It’s a temporary peak in demand with no impact. Our campaign is just an overreaction by a group of women to a perfectly rational and sensible decision by the Trust.
Now where have we heard that kind of thing before?
Women! You are overreacting to us putting the needs of male service users before yours!
Women! You are overreacting with your anxiety at being treated away from your homes and families!
Women! You just don’t understand how these things work, so do go ahead and STFU now won’t you!
Well, we’re not going to shut up.
Temporary or not, the closure should never have happened. Temporary or not, the needs of male service users are not more important than female service users. Temporary or not, the worry and anxiety felt by the women is real and harmful. Temporary or not, the costs incurred by families to visit their relatives are real and harmful. Temporary or not, the emotional distress of the families is real and harmful.
Temporary or not, denying women access to local inpatient care is harmful, discriminatory and should never have happened in the first place.
Temporary doesn't make it better.
They have told us publicly that it’s a temporary move that won’t last for weeks and weeks. That it’s to cope with a peak in demand for male beds, that of course has nothing to do with them closing 15 of them elsewhere in the county. And they’ve publicly stated that it’s not having a negative impact despite the women telling them that it is.
In their eyes this is surely a non-story now. It’s a temporary peak in demand with no impact. Our campaign is just an overreaction by a group of women to a perfectly rational and sensible decision by the Trust.
Now where have we heard that kind of thing before?
Women! You are overreacting to us putting the needs of male service users before yours!
Women! You are overreacting with your anxiety at being treated away from your homes and families!
Women! You just don’t understand how these things work, so do go ahead and STFU now won’t you!
Well, we’re not going to shut up.
Temporary or not, the closure should never have happened. Temporary or not, the needs of male service users are not more important than female service users. Temporary or not, the worry and anxiety felt by the women is real and harmful. Temporary or not, the costs incurred by families to visit their relatives are real and harmful. Temporary or not, the emotional distress of the families is real and harmful.
Temporary or not, denying women access to local inpatient care is harmful, discriminatory and should never have happened in the first place.
Temporary doesn't make it better.
Wednesday, 5 November 2014
Beds in the Orchard - We're just the tip of the Iceberg
While Beds in the Orchard is a very specific campaign in a small area, the funding of Mental Health services across the country is appalling. Lancashire Care NHS Trust, is just one trust battling with an ever decreasing budget.
David Cameron pledged to put mental health on the same footing as physical health. His party pledged to ring-fence NHS spending. But here we are in 2014 with the local trust having to cut its spending by 25% and women being denied local treatment.
Ours is just one story that is being repeated across the country. While the political parties vie to show themselves to be the most supportive of mental health, the actions of politicians and the Department of Health tell us that it is all words and rhetoric.
Adult mental health has always come down at the bottom of funding. Its not cute and fluffy. It isn't wide eyed children looking innocently up at the camera. It isn't images of people bravely fighting against the odds, despite the fact that we fight it ever day, and it doesn't have the pull of other illnesses when it comes to charitable funding.
We're the nutters on the bus, the ones who mutter to ourselves and perhaps the ones who are dressed strangely. We're the ones that its OK to take the piss out of and mock. We're not the ones that people want to fund; so what you find is an overstretched service doing their best to look after people who are really, really poorly and in need of help.
People are being let down everywhere from the young to the old. Cuts to CAHMS let down troubled teenagers and restricted access to care just sets them up for a life in and out of hospital. Where there used to be specialist geriatric units for people over the age of 60 with mental health problems, they now go into specialist nursing homes and their houses are sold for their care.
One in four people has a mental health issue. We're your colleagues, your children, your mum or dad. We're your friend and your neighbour. We deserve the right treatment at the right time, in the right place.
We don't look after people with mental health problems properly and sadly, it will need a major incident to happen before the government start funding it properly again. Cutting services and care is a false economy and one that costs the country more money than it saves by cutting funding.
The women of North Lancashire are just another victim of a service struggling to cope with demand.
Someone has to speak up. If its us, then so be it.
David Cameron pledged to put mental health on the same footing as physical health. His party pledged to ring-fence NHS spending. But here we are in 2014 with the local trust having to cut its spending by 25% and women being denied local treatment.
Ours is just one story that is being repeated across the country. While the political parties vie to show themselves to be the most supportive of mental health, the actions of politicians and the Department of Health tell us that it is all words and rhetoric.
Adult mental health has always come down at the bottom of funding. Its not cute and fluffy. It isn't wide eyed children looking innocently up at the camera. It isn't images of people bravely fighting against the odds, despite the fact that we fight it ever day, and it doesn't have the pull of other illnesses when it comes to charitable funding.
We're the nutters on the bus, the ones who mutter to ourselves and perhaps the ones who are dressed strangely. We're the ones that its OK to take the piss out of and mock. We're not the ones that people want to fund; so what you find is an overstretched service doing their best to look after people who are really, really poorly and in need of help.
People are being let down everywhere from the young to the old. Cuts to CAHMS let down troubled teenagers and restricted access to care just sets them up for a life in and out of hospital. Where there used to be specialist geriatric units for people over the age of 60 with mental health problems, they now go into specialist nursing homes and their houses are sold for their care.
One in four people has a mental health issue. We're your colleagues, your children, your mum or dad. We're your friend and your neighbour. We deserve the right treatment at the right time, in the right place.
We don't look after people with mental health problems properly and sadly, it will need a major incident to happen before the government start funding it properly again. Cutting services and care is a false economy and one that costs the country more money than it saves by cutting funding.
The women of North Lancashire are just another victim of a service struggling to cope with demand.
Someone has to speak up. If its us, then so be it.
Parity of Care - Why closing local inpatient beds discriminates against women.
There are many reasons why we at Beds in the Orchard are campaigning for local inpatient care for the women of North Lancashire. We've covered these in some of our previous posts. Isolation, financial cost, disruption, distress for both the service user and their families. Children separated from their parents. Women separated from their families. All with no chance of being returned to their local area.
When a section 3 can see you detained in hospital for 6 months, its glaringly obvious why being away from home for that long can have long lasting and negative effects for the women being treated.
But is this really discrimination?
The Trust tell us that this is due to "A peak in demand for male beds". Lets apply that to something else.
If there was a peak in demand for school places for boys, a school would not just take male pupils, they would also take female pupils, with both boys and girls having to go to other schools if there wasn't a place.
If there was a peak in demand for emergency care due to men having accidents, an A&E department wouldn't just treat men and send the women to a different area.
If there was a peak in demand with more men needing cardiac care than women needing cardiac care, a hospital wouldn't only treat men and send women out of the area.
So why is it acceptable when there are more men requiring psychiatric care than women, to only treat the men and send women out of the area?
Our position at Beds In the Orchard is that it is not acceptable at all.
When a section 3 can see you detained in hospital for 6 months, its glaringly obvious why being away from home for that long can have long lasting and negative effects for the women being treated.
But is this really discrimination?
The Trust tell us that this is due to "A peak in demand for male beds". Lets apply that to something else.
If there was a peak in demand for school places for boys, a school would not just take male pupils, they would also take female pupils, with both boys and girls having to go to other schools if there wasn't a place.
If there was a peak in demand for emergency care due to men having accidents, an A&E department wouldn't just treat men and send the women to a different area.
If there was a peak in demand with more men needing cardiac care than women needing cardiac care, a hospital wouldn't only treat men and send women out of the area.
So why is it acceptable when there are more men requiring psychiatric care than women, to only treat the men and send women out of the area?
Our position at Beds In the Orchard is that it is not acceptable at all.
More Freedom of Information
Another Freedom of Information Request has been sent to the Lancashire Care NHS Trust this morning. Today, we are looking for answers about equality, who is filling the beds and how Home Treatment has been expanded to meet the needs of the men and women no longer treated on Ward 18 or at The Orchard.
Dear Sir/Madam,
Please can you provide me with the following information.
1. The Equality Impact Assessment of closing female inpatient beds at The Orchard in Lancaster conducted by the Lancashire Care NHS Trust before the beds were closed to women.
2. The number of male patients from the East Lancashire region treated, or being treated in hospitals run by the Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust elsewhere in the county (Preston, Chorley, Ormskirk, Lancaster and Blackpool etc.) since the closure of Ward 18 at Burnley General Hospital.
3. The number of male patients transferred from Ward 18 in Burnley to The Orchard in Lancaster when Ward 18 was closed.
4. The number of male patients from East Lancashire treated in The Orchard since 01/09/14 to date.
5. The FTE of staff in the Crisis, Home Treatment and CCTT teams in Burnley and the surrounding area the months before, and then after the closure of Ward 18 in Burnley.
6. The FTE of staff in the Crisis, Home Treatment and CCTT teams in Lancaster and the surrounding area the month before, and after the closure of The Orchard to women.
Best regards,
Dear Sir/Madam,
Please can you provide me with the following information.
1. The Equality Impact Assessment of closing female inpatient beds at The Orchard in Lancaster conducted by the Lancashire Care NHS Trust before the beds were closed to women.
2. The number of male patients from the East Lancashire region treated, or being treated in hospitals run by the Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust elsewhere in the county (Preston, Chorley, Ormskirk, Lancaster and Blackpool etc.) since the closure of Ward 18 at Burnley General Hospital.
3. The number of male patients transferred from Ward 18 in Burnley to The Orchard in Lancaster when Ward 18 was closed.
4. The number of male patients from East Lancashire treated in The Orchard since 01/09/14 to date.
5. The FTE of staff in the Crisis, Home Treatment and CCTT teams in Burnley and the surrounding area the months before, and then after the closure of Ward 18 in Burnley.
6. The FTE of staff in the Crisis, Home Treatment and CCTT teams in Lancaster and the surrounding area the month before, and after the closure of The Orchard to women.
Best regards,
Tuesday, 4 November 2014
Who We Are and What You Can Do To Help
Beds In The Orchard is a campaign for the reinstatement of female
psychiatric inpatient provision at The Orchard hospital in Lancaster.
The ward was closed to women in October 2014, without any consultation
with local services users or the wider community. Women needing
inpatient care are now sent between 30 - 60+ miles from their homes for
treatment.
This closure discriminates against women in the local area and causes unnecessary distress and isolation of vulnerable women. While women have always been sent out of area due to bed shortages, they previously would be moved back into area when a bed became free. Now they must remain out of area for treatment that can see them separated from their families, friends and support networks for many months.
This closure discriminates against women in the local area and causes unnecessary distress and isolation of vulnerable women. While women have always been sent out of area due to bed shortages, they previously would be moved back into area when a bed became free. Now they must remain out of area for treatment that can see them separated from their families, friends and support networks for many months.
The Trust say this is temporary to cope with a peak in demand for male beds but it comes after closing 15 male beds elsewhere in the Trust and their own employees tell us that it's until the Harbour opens in Blackpool, scheduled for March 2015. This is not acceptable. Women are being hurt now.
What you can do to help
As well as this blog we are also on Twitter @OrchardBeds - #bedsintheorchard.
What you can do to help
As well as this blog we are also on Twitter @OrchardBeds - #bedsintheorchard.
Contact us by email on bedsintheorchard @ gmail . com
You can now also sign our on-line petition - Click Here
Please share our story and if you're on twitter, retweet our posts to who may be interested in supporting our campaign. You can tweet the Trust directly on @LancashireCare.
We need help to let the Trust and local Clinical Commissioning groups know that this is not acceptable and should be reversed as soon as possible.
The Deputy Network Director has recently become the voice of the Trust on this issue. You can mail him directly - Keith.Dibble@lancashirecare.nhs.uk
If you are not on twitter, please see the following pages on our blog for other contacts.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/who-do-i-twio.html
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/10/i-want-to-make-some-noise-about-this.html
If you are not sure what to write when you complain, we have a letter that you can edit.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/not-sure-what-to-write-when-you-complain.html
The closure of beds in Lancaster is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to poor funding of Mental Health across the UK.
Thank you for helping us make a difference.
You can now also sign our on-line petition - Click Here
Please share our story and if you're on twitter, retweet our posts to who may be interested in supporting our campaign. You can tweet the Trust directly on @LancashireCare.
We need help to let the Trust and local Clinical Commissioning groups know that this is not acceptable and should be reversed as soon as possible.
The Deputy Network Director has recently become the voice of the Trust on this issue. You can mail him directly - Keith.Dibble@lancashirecare.nhs.uk
If you are not on twitter, please see the following pages on our blog for other contacts.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/who-do-i-twio.html
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/10/i-want-to-make-some-noise-about-this.html
If you are not sure what to write when you complain, we have a letter that you can edit.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/not-sure-what-to-write-when-you-complain.html
The closure of beds in Lancaster is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to poor funding of Mental Health across the UK.
Thank you for helping us make a difference.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)