LCFT Use a Women's Refuge for female service user in MH Crisis.
The demand for beds in North Lancashire continues unabated, with female referrals now matching those of men. With the Trust's inpatient facilities full and a substantial number of private beds being used, getting inpatient treatment is now almost impossible.
Yesterday a female service user from North Lancashire was sent to a women's refuge after being told there were no female beds available anywhere. Even though she has a chronic mental health condition and was experiencing psychotic symptoms brought on by stress, she was assessed as "too sane" to be admitted to a private bed and since the stress was due to issues within the home, the only place they could send her to was a woman's refuge.
Is this what it's come to? Really?
Is a refuge really the right place for someone experiencing a mental health crisis? Would a man be sent to a refuge, or would he be found a bed somewhere? It's a damned serious question and one that has to be asked.
Women's refuges are such an important resource. For a Mental Health Trust to use them as a back up to a service creaking under the strain of inadequate provision would seem to be a misuse of that service.
Having spoken to the woman in question, she is concerned about relapsing and knows there is nothing she can do, as there's literally no room at the LCFT Inn.
Showing posts with label bed closures. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bed closures. Show all posts
Wednesday, 21 January 2015
Tuesday, 2 December 2014
So, will we get the beds back?
The answer to this is "yes, at some point, but it may not be until The Harbour opens."
This is obviously very disappointing to us all. This will mean that The Orchard will have been closed to women for at least 6 months. Half a year is not a short term temporary closure, it is a long period of time for women to be denied local care and experience all of the negative effects.
The Trust were unable to offer any guarantees about when the ward will be reopened to women, although they assured us that they are reviewing this regularly.
The problem is that they're unable to cope with the demand for male beds, so have no choice to keep the ward male only. Attempts to move some beds back have not worked. This is due to the lack of capacity caused by closing the 22 male beds.
Is it just the women in North Lancashire who have lost out?
Yes. Although there have been small losses elsewhere, the impact has focussed on North Lancashire.
The first contingency plans were to close 5 female beds and change those to male. Two of these were the swing beds at The Orchard. The closure of the whole ward means that the loss of 22 male beds has resulted in a total loss of 11 female beds, 8 of which are in Lancaster.
The first contingency plans were to close 5 female beds and change those to male. Two of these were the swing beds at The Orchard. The closure of the whole ward means that the loss of 22 male beds has resulted in a total loss of 11 female beds, 8 of which are in Lancaster.
Is there ANY good news?
Yes and no...
We've been assured that The Orchard will return to mixed use as soon as it's feasible, though with the usual caveat that it could run to when The Harbour opens. It's difficult for us to see this as good news when we already had that information.
More positively, it was made clear that the intention is to absolutely return the ward to mixed sex and that there are further plans for investment, such as the appointment of an additional Pdoc.
More positively, it was made clear that the intention is to absolutely return the ward to mixed sex and that there are further plans for investment, such as the appointment of an additional Pdoc.
The Consultant Psychiatrist who attended the meeting to give clinical input was keen to point out that they wanted the ward to return to mixed sex as it was a more therapeutic environment when the ward is mixed. He also showed genuine concern about the in the impact of the closure.
The Trust are keen to keep dialogue open between themselves and the Campaign and our spokesperson will keep this dialogue going. The Trust have assured us that the use of the beds is under constant review and that they are accountable to the CCGs that it is only temporary. By having direct communication we can keep up to date with what is happening.
Anything else?
We suggested an interim measure to help the women and their families and this is going to be discussed by the Trust, though they felt it may not be feasible. We have actioned them to look into other ways that they could help.
We also raised some feedback as to how the trust could look at how it deals with complaints. They have taken this on-board.
The Trust are keen to keep dialogue open between themselves and the Campaign and our spokesperson will keep this dialogue going. The Trust have assured us that the use of the beds is under constant review and that they are accountable to the CCGs that it is only temporary. By having direct communication we can keep up to date with what is happening.
Anything else?
We suggested an interim measure to help the women and their families and this is going to be discussed by the Trust, though they felt it may not be feasible. We have actioned them to look into other ways that they could help.
We also raised some feedback as to how the trust could look at how it deals with complaints. They have taken this on-board.
Strategy is no Excuse for In-Year Budget Cuts
Much has been made about the Strategy of the LCFT to reduce the number of inpatient beds while increasing the input from the community teams.
In our meeting yesterday, we strongly challenged the closure of the 22 beds in Burnley as it was clear that decision had gone ahead with full acknowledgement that the loss of those beds was unmanageable, thus resulting in The Orchard being closed to women.
Mr. Dibble referred back to their strategy to reduce the number of inpatient beds and their major planning process of 2006 that had involved wide consultation and full due process. This was quoted that as a reason behind the closure of Ward 18 as it was part of the strategic plan.
We disagreed that you could refer back to an 8 year old plan to explain the closure of a ward to women in 2014. Mr. Dibble disagreed with us, as in his experience plans involving PFI, for example can take many years.
Our issue with this is that Strategy lays out the long term goals of an organisation, however, Strategy should not result in a failure to deliver required services.
We are not talking about the long term strategic plan, we are talking about a short term measure to deliver savings to the in-year budget knowing that it was not sustainable operationally and therefore resulted in the Trust being unable to deliver its services as required.
Blaming strategic plans for operational failures does not make business sense.
To summarise:-
This is not acceptable.
In our meeting yesterday, we strongly challenged the closure of the 22 beds in Burnley as it was clear that decision had gone ahead with full acknowledgement that the loss of those beds was unmanageable, thus resulting in The Orchard being closed to women.
Mr. Dibble referred back to their strategy to reduce the number of inpatient beds and their major planning process of 2006 that had involved wide consultation and full due process. This was quoted that as a reason behind the closure of Ward 18 as it was part of the strategic plan.
We disagreed that you could refer back to an 8 year old plan to explain the closure of a ward to women in 2014. Mr. Dibble disagreed with us, as in his experience plans involving PFI, for example can take many years.
Our issue with this is that Strategy lays out the long term goals of an organisation, however, Strategy should not result in a failure to deliver required services.
We are not talking about the long term strategic plan, we are talking about a short term measure to deliver savings to the in-year budget knowing that it was not sustainable operationally and therefore resulted in the Trust being unable to deliver its services as required.
Blaming strategic plans for operational failures does not make business sense.
To summarise:-
- The Trust will have had to make cost savings within year. This is part of the yearly budget plan, not the Strategic Capital Investment plan.
- The 22 beds were closed as part of the yearly budget plan, not the Strategic Capital Investment plan.
- It is not the overall LCFT patient care strategy that caused the closure of The Orchard to women, it was the financial pressures and required budget savings within this financial year
- A decision was made to reduce services knowing there wasn't capacity to manage that change. This is not a strategic issue. That is financial and operational.
This is not acceptable.
Wednesday, 26 November 2014
How many more women will be hurt before this changes?
One of our campaigners has some important questions.
How many more women will be hurt before this changes? I'm crying out to you here.
I'm seeing my friends sent away. Hearing the hurt in their voices. They echo in my head at night.
Why are you doing this to us? You make these changes and don't think it through. You are meant to care for us, but you see pound signs not people.
What will it take for it to change? A death? Will that be the moment it changes, when you can't ignore it any more.
When someone says that everything is so shit and there's no one who knows them near by to help, so they call it a day.
I don't think that would do it. You'd find a way to say you weren't involved, that it would have happened anyway. We'll know better. We all will.
Enough now. Enough. Mums away from their kids at Christmas is next on the list. Daughters and sisters, friends and family ill and alone.
You're heartless in your offices. Do something. I'm crying out to you here.
How many more women will be hurt before this changes? I'm crying out to you here.
I'm seeing my friends sent away. Hearing the hurt in their voices. They echo in my head at night.
Why are you doing this to us? You make these changes and don't think it through. You are meant to care for us, but you see pound signs not people.
What will it take for it to change? A death? Will that be the moment it changes, when you can't ignore it any more.
When someone says that everything is so shit and there's no one who knows them near by to help, so they call it a day.
I don't think that would do it. You'd find a way to say you weren't involved, that it would have happened anyway. We'll know better. We all will.
Enough now. Enough. Mums away from their kids at Christmas is next on the list. Daughters and sisters, friends and family ill and alone.
You're heartless in your offices. Do something. I'm crying out to you here.
Thursday, 13 November 2014
A letter from the Trust, via a local MP
We'd like to take the time to thank David Morris MP, who a number of local service users contacted at the start of our campaign. He took the time to look into the matter and reply to each of us outlining what he had done and the response he had from the Trust. The letter from the trust that he forwarded is below.
Dear
Dear
Thank you for your email.
As
the Member of Parliament I am not directly responsible for the day to
day running’s of individual health services, however I had
asked the Lancashire Care Trust for a briefing on what was happening on
the unit and why the decision to close the female beds have been made.
I
have enclosed a copy of the letter below for your information, but I am
pleased to say that this move is only a temporary arrangement
to deal with a period where there are more male referrals than female
ones and the female beds will be reinstated once the male referrals
return to a normal level. The letter also states that at certain periods
of the year female referrals rise over male figures
and on these incidences the unit will be made fully female to deal with
the demand for beds.
I trust the briefing attached addresses all of the questions you have about this change, however if you would like me to ask the
Trust any more questions on your behalf, please contact me again and I will be more than happy to do so.
Yours Sincerely
David Morris MP
Morecambe and Lunesdale
House of Commons
London
SW1A 0AA
Dear David
As you are aware, Lancashire Care provide 18 beds
for adults aged 18 and over with a mental health problem in The Orchard
in Lancaster. Usually this caters for male and female service users but
temporarily we are using The Orchard as a
male only unit.
The reason for this is that there has been an
increase in the number of male referrals and a decrease in the number of
female referrals; there are currently empty female beds in Lancashire.
This is a seasonal fluctuation and historically
there is often an increase in male admissions at this time of year.
Similarly, demand for female beds can often rise in the spring time. In
order to respond to these fluctuations, the Trust’s inpatient services
have been designed so that the ratio of male
and female beds can be flexed to respond to meet demand accordingly.
A campaign group has been started called “Beds In
The Orchard” which describes itself as “a campaign for the reinstatement
of female psychiatric inpatient provision at The Orchard hospital in
Lancaster”. The group are tweeting from the
handle @OrchardBeds and, amongst other things, are encouraging people
to contact their MP. The group have also contacted the local media and
will feature on Radio Lancashire at 7am on 4 November; the Trust will
also be fielding a representative for this.
I wanted to brief you that this arrangement will be
for a short period of time and bed demand is under constant monitoring.
This temporary measure has been in place for a month and during this
time, approximately 6 females from the North
Lancashire area have been admitted to a Trust facility in the wider
Lancashire locality. Bed usage changes on a daily basis and as soon as
the peak in male admissions has settled back to normal rates, The
Orchard will revert back to being a mixed sex facility.
In the same way that the service has temporarily been switched to
accommodate the increase in male admissions at this time, The Orchard
and the Trust’s other inpatient facilities have the flexibility to
respond to an increase in female activity too. The Trust’s
new facilities have been designed with this in mind and feature ‘swing
beds’ so that the ratio of male/female beds can be altered in line with
demand which is a dynamic situation.
It is important to note that the Trust provides
beds on a pan Lancashire basis. Whilst every effort is made to place
people as close to their home as possible, the most local unit may not
always be the most appropriate for a person and
placement is also determined by clinical need as well as location. The
Trust is committed to keeping people in the Lancashire locality and
reducing the number of people being treated outside of this area.
Future inpatient services will be provided from
four purpose built inpatient units including The Orchard in Lancaster
and The Harbour in Blackpool.
Kind regards
Steve
Steve Winterson
Engagement Director
Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust
Monday, 10 November 2014
We go national again as the Huffington Post picks up our story!
While at first we look like a small local campaign, it seems that the Beds in the Orchard has touched a nerve within the wider community with those passionate about women's rights and good health care taking up our cause.
Today, our campaign was picked up by one of team from The Huffington Post, a popular on-line news paper and the article is available to read on their site now.
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/louise-pennington/closing-womens-psychiatri_b_6131878.html
We're proud of what we are doing here and grateful for the support we are getting. Lets hope we make a real change.
Today, our campaign was picked up by one of team from The Huffington Post, a popular on-line news paper and the article is available to read on their site now.
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/louise-pennington/closing-womens-psychiatri_b_6131878.html
We're proud of what we are doing here and grateful for the support we are getting. Lets hope we make a real change.
Wednesday, 5 November 2014
More Freedom of Information
Another Freedom of Information Request has been sent to the Lancashire Care NHS Trust this morning. Today, we are looking for answers about equality, who is filling the beds and how Home Treatment has been expanded to meet the needs of the men and women no longer treated on Ward 18 or at The Orchard.
Dear Sir/Madam,
Please can you provide me with the following information.
1. The Equality Impact Assessment of closing female inpatient beds at The Orchard in Lancaster conducted by the Lancashire Care NHS Trust before the beds were closed to women.
2. The number of male patients from the East Lancashire region treated, or being treated in hospitals run by the Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust elsewhere in the county (Preston, Chorley, Ormskirk, Lancaster and Blackpool etc.) since the closure of Ward 18 at Burnley General Hospital.
3. The number of male patients transferred from Ward 18 in Burnley to The Orchard in Lancaster when Ward 18 was closed.
4. The number of male patients from East Lancashire treated in The Orchard since 01/09/14 to date.
5. The FTE of staff in the Crisis, Home Treatment and CCTT teams in Burnley and the surrounding area the months before, and then after the closure of Ward 18 in Burnley.
6. The FTE of staff in the Crisis, Home Treatment and CCTT teams in Lancaster and the surrounding area the month before, and after the closure of The Orchard to women.
Best regards,
Dear Sir/Madam,
Please can you provide me with the following information.
1. The Equality Impact Assessment of closing female inpatient beds at The Orchard in Lancaster conducted by the Lancashire Care NHS Trust before the beds were closed to women.
2. The number of male patients from the East Lancashire region treated, or being treated in hospitals run by the Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust elsewhere in the county (Preston, Chorley, Ormskirk, Lancaster and Blackpool etc.) since the closure of Ward 18 at Burnley General Hospital.
3. The number of male patients transferred from Ward 18 in Burnley to The Orchard in Lancaster when Ward 18 was closed.
4. The number of male patients from East Lancashire treated in The Orchard since 01/09/14 to date.
5. The FTE of staff in the Crisis, Home Treatment and CCTT teams in Burnley and the surrounding area the months before, and then after the closure of Ward 18 in Burnley.
6. The FTE of staff in the Crisis, Home Treatment and CCTT teams in Lancaster and the surrounding area the month before, and after the closure of The Orchard to women.
Best regards,
Tuesday, 4 November 2014
"It is not the intention for this to run for weeks and weeks"
We've spent this evening going over Claire's interview on BBC Radio Lancashire and the response to our campaign from Keith Dibble, the Deputy Director of the Lancashire Care NHS Trust.
We were going to post a long reply, but can actually summarise quite swiftly.
The County
There were a number of mentions by Keith about the County, for example "Balance across the county" and "Cross county requirement".
If there is a cross county requirement then removing 15 male beds will have changed the balance across the county of male beds.
We'll be submitting a FOI request about how many men from the Burnley area are being treated in the west and north of the county.
Home Treatment
Home treatment is indeed preferable. Sadly the crisis and home treatment teams are not augmented when beds are closed. Existing teams have an ever expanding case-load and less people are expected to look after more Service Users.
We doubt that when the male beds in Burnley were closed, the home treatment teams were expanded in that area and we doubt that when the female beds were closed in Lancaster that the home treatment teams were expanded in that area either.
Another Freedom of Information Request will be sent out tomorrow so we can confirm that to you.
(Our FOI person is going to have a busy day)
Clinical Priorities
Beds in the Orchard has never suggested that people requiring PICU care etc. should be treated at The Orchard. We all have personal experience of being unwell and know that some women need to be treated in specialist units.
However the women being sent away from Lancaster for treatment do not all need specialist treatment and they would benefit more from local care.
It appears that the trust position is that the Clinical Priorities are caring for the men of North Lancashire after the balance across the county was tipped by the closure of male beds.
Length of Closure
Keith stated that it is "Not the intention for this to run for weeks and weeks."
This goes against information we have been given, but will be pleased if this turns out to be correct. We will continue to campaign for the female beds at The Orchard to be reopened until provision for women is restored and also to ensure that this statement from the trust is upheld.
We will continue to actively publicise the closure of the beds by the Trust and we will be further investigating at the treatment of women in Mental Health Services run by the Lancashire Care NHS Trust.
Financial Reasons
Keith said there were no financial reasons for the closure of beds. However, since the Trust has to deliver a 25% cut in expenditure as directed by the Department of Health, we suspect that financial pressures may well be involved.
We were going to post a long reply, but can actually summarise quite swiftly.
The County
There were a number of mentions by Keith about the County, for example "Balance across the county" and "Cross county requirement".
If there is a cross county requirement then removing 15 male beds will have changed the balance across the county of male beds.
We'll be submitting a FOI request about how many men from the Burnley area are being treated in the west and north of the county.
Home Treatment
Home treatment is indeed preferable. Sadly the crisis and home treatment teams are not augmented when beds are closed. Existing teams have an ever expanding case-load and less people are expected to look after more Service Users.
We doubt that when the male beds in Burnley were closed, the home treatment teams were expanded in that area and we doubt that when the female beds were closed in Lancaster that the home treatment teams were expanded in that area either.
Another Freedom of Information Request will be sent out tomorrow so we can confirm that to you.
(Our FOI person is going to have a busy day)
Clinical Priorities
Beds in the Orchard has never suggested that people requiring PICU care etc. should be treated at The Orchard. We all have personal experience of being unwell and know that some women need to be treated in specialist units.
However the women being sent away from Lancaster for treatment do not all need specialist treatment and they would benefit more from local care.
It appears that the trust position is that the Clinical Priorities are caring for the men of North Lancashire after the balance across the county was tipped by the closure of male beds.
Length of Closure
Keith stated that it is "Not the intention for this to run for weeks and weeks."
This goes against information we have been given, but will be pleased if this turns out to be correct. We will continue to campaign for the female beds at The Orchard to be reopened until provision for women is restored and also to ensure that this statement from the trust is upheld.
We will continue to actively publicise the closure of the beds by the Trust and we will be further investigating at the treatment of women in Mental Health Services run by the Lancashire Care NHS Trust.
Financial Reasons
Keith said there were no financial reasons for the closure of beds. However, since the Trust has to deliver a 25% cut in expenditure as directed by the Department of Health, we suspect that financial pressures may well be involved.
Beds in the Orchard takes on the Trust on BBC Radio Lancashire
If you are from out of the county or just weren't awake at 7am this morning, you can listen again on their website - http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0293ql6. The podcast is available for 7 days from today.
Listen to Claire speaking on behalf of the Beds in the Orchard Campaign at around 7am and the response from Deputy Network Director of Lancashire Care NHS Trust at around 8am.
A lot of what Claire said is already on this blog. She's kicking herself slightly about missing some things out, but it was Live Radio and there was a lot to say in a small space of time.
A quick take on the Trusts response:
If this is 'county wide' care, then you really can't then argue that the closure of 15 male beds in the county wouldn't have an impact on the need for male beds in the county.
Travel expenses - If they have to be claimed back, then families without the money to pay up front will still be unable to visit their relatives.
We were delighted to hear that female beds will be open back in The Orchard 'as soon as possible'. We've heard you say that now, Lancashire Care. "As soon as possible" is NOT March 2015 when the Harbour is due to open.
This campaign will continue to run and will continue to apply pressure until the female beds are reinstated at the Orchard.
Listen to Claire speaking on behalf of the Beds in the Orchard Campaign at around 7am and the response from Deputy Network Director of Lancashire Care NHS Trust at around 8am.
A lot of what Claire said is already on this blog. She's kicking herself slightly about missing some things out, but it was Live Radio and there was a lot to say in a small space of time.
A quick take on the Trusts response:
If this is 'county wide' care, then you really can't then argue that the closure of 15 male beds in the county wouldn't have an impact on the need for male beds in the county.
Travel expenses - If they have to be claimed back, then families without the money to pay up front will still be unable to visit their relatives.
We were delighted to hear that female beds will be open back in The Orchard 'as soon as possible'. We've heard you say that now, Lancashire Care. "As soon as possible" is NOT March 2015 when the Harbour is due to open.
This campaign will continue to run and will continue to apply pressure until the female beds are reinstated at the Orchard.
Monday, 3 November 2014
For those of you who don't twitter - Our take on the response from Lancashire Care
The Beds in the Orchard Campaign received its first official response from the Trust this afternoon via our Twitter account @OrchardBeds from @LancashireCare.
Here's what they had to say and, of course, our response.
@OrchardBeds The decision to operate male only beds at The Orchard is a temporary measure and is under constant review. (1/5)
We can't argue about whether or not this is true as we only have this statement from the Trust about it. However; we do know that some Trust staff have been advised The Orchard may revert back to mixed provision once The Harbour opens in March 2015, suggesting that it is not under constant review as the decision has already been made. We are open to concede there may have been a communication problem if staff have not been informed about it remaining male only until the opening of The Harbour.
Regardless of whether this is temporary or not, it is impacting women and families now. It is hurting female service users now and there remains no clinical benefit to women from the closure.
@OrchardBeds There is a peak in demand for male beds & a reduction in demand for female beds - we have empty female beds at present. (2/5)
Two responses here. Firstly, it is likely that the peak in demand for male beds is linked to the trust closing a 15 bed male ward in Burnley and it is rather disingenuous to cite demand for male beds being the driving factor after closing 15 of them.
Secondly, the point about empty female beds is slightly misleading. The status of beds can change on an hourly basis. From personal experience a bed can be taken in the time it takes to have a consultation with your psychiatrist about whether you should go into hospital or not. A freedom of information request has already been submitted to the trust about how many women they've sent out of area in the last 4 years, often to private hospitals that should clarify demand.
We also directed them to this post - http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/10/is-based-on-need-self-fulfilling.html
This isn't about empty beds. Its about denying a whole group of service users access to local inpatient care solely based on their sex.
@OrchardBeds All Trust facilities have the ability to flex male/female beds in line with demand. (3/5)
This is indeed True. The Orchard had two 'swing' beds that could change between male and female. There were 10 fixed male beds and 6 fixed female beds. Up until recently, the two swing beds were female. The trust could have swung those beds to male, giving them 12 male and 6 female beds at The Orchard. Instead they decided to deny access to a whole group of service users from a wide area.
It is rather disappointing that the Trust sees removing access to local inpatient care to all women in the Lancaster area as 'flexing'.
@OrchardBeds The Orchard will revert to mixed sex as soon as this is clinically appropriate. (4/5)
There's nothing we can really say about this other than, how is it clinically appropriate to deny women access to local inpatient care. No, seriously. Our twitter handler has replied that we will be happy to discuss this with someone qualified to explain the clinical benefits to women of sending them out of the area for treatment.
@OrchardBeds We would be happy to discuss this further with you and you can contact us on communications@lancashirecare.nhs.uk (5/5)
One of our team had already emailed the complaints department with the letter we published here
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/not-sure-what-to-write-when-you-complain.html
We will publish their response as soon as they receive it.
Here's what they had to say and, of course, our response.
@OrchardBeds The decision to operate male only beds at The Orchard is a temporary measure and is under constant review. (1/5)
We can't argue about whether or not this is true as we only have this statement from the Trust about it. However; we do know that some Trust staff have been advised The Orchard may revert back to mixed provision once The Harbour opens in March 2015, suggesting that it is not under constant review as the decision has already been made. We are open to concede there may have been a communication problem if staff have not been informed about it remaining male only until the opening of The Harbour.
Regardless of whether this is temporary or not, it is impacting women and families now. It is hurting female service users now and there remains no clinical benefit to women from the closure.
@OrchardBeds There is a peak in demand for male beds & a reduction in demand for female beds - we have empty female beds at present. (2/5)
Two responses here. Firstly, it is likely that the peak in demand for male beds is linked to the trust closing a 15 bed male ward in Burnley and it is rather disingenuous to cite demand for male beds being the driving factor after closing 15 of them.
Secondly, the point about empty female beds is slightly misleading. The status of beds can change on an hourly basis. From personal experience a bed can be taken in the time it takes to have a consultation with your psychiatrist about whether you should go into hospital or not. A freedom of information request has already been submitted to the trust about how many women they've sent out of area in the last 4 years, often to private hospitals that should clarify demand.
We also directed them to this post - http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/10/is-based-on-need-self-fulfilling.html
This isn't about empty beds. Its about denying a whole group of service users access to local inpatient care solely based on their sex.
@OrchardBeds All Trust facilities have the ability to flex male/female beds in line with demand. (3/5)
This is indeed True. The Orchard had two 'swing' beds that could change between male and female. There were 10 fixed male beds and 6 fixed female beds. Up until recently, the two swing beds were female. The trust could have swung those beds to male, giving them 12 male and 6 female beds at The Orchard. Instead they decided to deny access to a whole group of service users from a wide area.
It is rather disappointing that the Trust sees removing access to local inpatient care to all women in the Lancaster area as 'flexing'.
@OrchardBeds The Orchard will revert to mixed sex as soon as this is clinically appropriate. (4/5)
There's nothing we can really say about this other than, how is it clinically appropriate to deny women access to local inpatient care. No, seriously. Our twitter handler has replied that we will be happy to discuss this with someone qualified to explain the clinical benefits to women of sending them out of the area for treatment.
@OrchardBeds We would be happy to discuss this further with you and you can contact us on communications@lancashirecare.nhs.uk (5/5)
One of our team had already emailed the complaints department with the letter we published here
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/not-sure-what-to-write-when-you-complain.html
We will publish their response as soon as they receive it.
There's no trusting the Trust
A Source at the Lancashire Care NHS Trust today said that closing The Orchard to women is a 'temporary measure' until the new hospital "The Harbour" is opened in Blackpool.
This is a step away from the previous reasons of protecting the vulnerable, but could cover their reason of it being 'based on need'.
So why do they need more male beds now?
Following further enquires and investigation, we discovered that just weeks before The Orchard was closed to women, they closed Ward 18, a 15 bed male psychiatric ward in Burnley, with no means to cater for the number of beds they knew they needed.
If the Trust closes male beds, they should mitigate that closure by providing treatment in the community to the men they otherwise should have admitted as inpatients. Instead, they withdrew inpatient care to women of a large area of the trust. This is not acceptable.
It's the women of North Lancashire who are paying for this cost saving exercise. It is the women of North Lancashire who are being denied local treatment and its their families who are paying the cost in time, travel and disruption for this decision.
Lancashire Care is failing in its duty of care to the women it is meant to treat and support.
It has to change.
This is a step away from the previous reasons of protecting the vulnerable, but could cover their reason of it being 'based on need'.
So why do they need more male beds now?
Following further enquires and investigation, we discovered that just weeks before The Orchard was closed to women, they closed Ward 18, a 15 bed male psychiatric ward in Burnley, with no means to cater for the number of beds they knew they needed.
If the Trust closes male beds, they should mitigate that closure by providing treatment in the community to the men they otherwise should have admitted as inpatients. Instead, they withdrew inpatient care to women of a large area of the trust. This is not acceptable.
It's the women of North Lancashire who are paying for this cost saving exercise. It is the women of North Lancashire who are being denied local treatment and its their families who are paying the cost in time, travel and disruption for this decision.
Lancashire Care is failing in its duty of care to the women it is meant to treat and support.
It has to change.
Sunday, 2 November 2014
Orchard Beds Campaign is published in Everyday Victim Blaming!
http://everydayvictimblaming.com/discussions/lancashire-care-nhs-trust-delivers-a-stark-example-of-victim-blaming/
Please help us get female inpatient care back for the women of Lancaster and district. Contacts and addresses below.
If you tweet - tweet @lancashirecare.
Please help us get female inpatient care back for the women of Lancaster and district. Contacts and addresses below.
If you tweet - tweet @lancashirecare.
Saturday, 1 November 2014
Not sure what to write when you complain?
If you're not sure what to write when you complain, below is a letter that you can use or edit to create your own.
2. The change will disproportionately affect women and families on low incomes who are unable to meet the costs of travel to visit their relative.
3. Women are less likely to seek help and their relatives less likely to ask for help, knowing that they will be sent out of the area for the duration of their treatment. This may result in increased detentions under the Mental Health Act with women unwilling to accept voluntary admissions, or by their condition deteriorating until detention is inevitable. Women will be more likely to press for early discharge, which is well documented as a cause of readmission.
4. The closure will do nothing to protect vulnerable women. Treatment in an unfamiliar place with no local support will increase their vulnerability. If there are issues with male-to-female aggression in an inpatient setting then this should be addressed, rather than deny women access to services.
5. If lack of male beds is an issue then that should be addressed by the Trust by looking to increase the number of male beds without denying access to a whole group of people under their care. Women should not be denied local access to inpatient psychiatric care due to a lack of male beds. The needs of women with mental illness are not less important than the needs of men. The need for women to be close to their families, children and support networks is not less important than male beds.
To whom it may concern,
I am writing to complain about the closure of The Orchard in
Lancaster to female patients. This move
will have significant and lasting implications for the women and should be
reconsidered.
2. The change will disproportionately affect women and families on low incomes who are unable to meet the costs of travel to visit their relative.
3. Women are less likely to seek help and their relatives less likely to ask for help, knowing that they will be sent out of the area for the duration of their treatment. This may result in increased detentions under the Mental Health Act with women unwilling to accept voluntary admissions, or by their condition deteriorating until detention is inevitable. Women will be more likely to press for early discharge, which is well documented as a cause of readmission.
4. The closure will do nothing to protect vulnerable women. Treatment in an unfamiliar place with no local support will increase their vulnerability. If there are issues with male-to-female aggression in an inpatient setting then this should be addressed, rather than deny women access to services.
5. If lack of male beds is an issue then that should be addressed by the Trust by looking to increase the number of male beds without denying access to a whole group of people under their care. Women should not be denied local access to inpatient psychiatric care due to a lack of male beds. The needs of women with mental illness are not less important than the needs of men. The need for women to be close to their families, children and support networks is not less important than male beds.
Overall, this closure has no clinical benefits for women and
will result in negative impacts on their health. This would appear to be a failure in your
duty of care to the women of Lancaster and district, and should be reversed as
soon as possible.
Best regards,
Friday, 31 October 2014
Freedom of Information Part 2
How many psychiatric beds have been closed since 2011? Are there more female than male beds closed?
I've asked england.contactus@nhs.net - the NHS FOI request email address for England.
Dear Sir/Madam,
Please can you provide me with the following information.
1. How many male psychiatric beds have been closed Nationally in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014 to date.
2. How many female psychiatric beds have been closed Nationally in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014 to date.
3. How many male psychiatric beds have been closed in Lancashire in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014 to date.
4. How many female psychiatric beds have been closed in Lancashire in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014 to date.
Best regards,
I've asked england.contactus@nhs.net - the NHS FOI request email address for England.
Dear Sir/Madam,
Please can you provide me with the following information.
1. How many male psychiatric beds have been closed Nationally in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014 to date.
2. How many female psychiatric beds have been closed Nationally in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014 to date.
3. How many male psychiatric beds have been closed in Lancashire in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014 to date.
4. How many female psychiatric beds have been closed in Lancashire in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014 to date.
Best regards,
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)