Showing posts with label sexism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sexism. Show all posts

Thursday, 20 November 2014

How culture shapes the actions of an organisation.

Guest Post
 
Sat in my living room last week I found myself watching "It was Acceptable in the 70s", a Channel 4 program that reviewed TV shown in the 1970s through the eyes of a modern day audience. There was one scene from The Professionals where a screaming woman was slapped, her shirt torn open and then refastened by the suave detective, along with a 'saucy' comment from his colleague.

Looking back now, the whole scene is blatantly sexist, but in the 1970s the culture of the UK was still getting its head around equal rights for women and violence and sexual abuse towards women was so unremarkable that it could be included in prime time television, without so much of an eyebrow being raised. 

All of the programs shown demonstrated how sexism, was so ingrained into the culture at that point in time that it could be blatant - rather than today where it sneaks in subversively, but not without comment.

When something is endemic in a culture, it will go unnoticed as it is unremarkable. 

It's not only society that has a culture and an ethos.  Companies and organisations have them too.  The culture of an organisation shapes its behaviour and the attitudes of the people in it.  It enables certain types of behaviour and discourages others.

To understand the culture of an organisation, do not look at the words it uses, but to their actions and outcomes.  For example, the company that states it invests in its workforce, but doesn't notice workplace bullying and has a high staff turnover.  The organisation that says it prides itself on customer service, but has little repeat business and a large number of customer complaints.

In the same way, if an organisation talks of equality, but behaves in a discriminatory way,  it suggests that those attitudes are embedded into the culture of that organisation, making it unremarkable, so it passes without notice.

Is this what has happened here?  Is discriminating against women so unremarkable that it can pass without comment?

This is the question I have asked myself since reading about the Beds in the Orchard campaign.  How discriminating against one group of people in an area, solely on their sex could pass unnoticed and without comment. Perhaps I'd have been less shocked if it was in the private sector where inequality sometimes slips under the radar, but for a public sector organisation like the NHS it is remarkable that it happened at all.

The statements made by the Trust about this closure are even more surprising with no acknowledgement whatsoever that their actions could be seen as anything other than reasonable.

That is why I ask.  What is the culture of the Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust?  I'm looking beyond their words in the on-line Annual Reviews and Equality Impact Assessments and straight at their actions. When I do, I am concerned about what I see.

Kath B

Tuesday, 18 November 2014

A big "Thanks" to Eric Ollerenshaw and a "Thanks for Nothing to the Trust"

Our other lovely MP Eric Ollerenshaw has got back to us as well as David Morris MP.

Both of them have had the same utterly disingenuous statement from from the LCFT.

This is the statement that:-

Doesn't mention that they've never removed inpatient care for women in this area before.

Doesn't mention the closure of male beds elsewhere in the county before  they closed The Orchard to women.

Talks about seasonal fluctuations, with the insinuation that closing a whole ward to one sex is a common event, or that they would do the same to men in spring - which they have never done before either.

This casual sexism, misleading by omission and dismissal of concerns raised by the Service Users they are meant to support needs to stop.

Saturday, 8 November 2014

The Equality Act 2010 - How is this not discrimination?

The Equality Act of 2010 sets out a list of Protected Characteristics.  These are: (in no particular order)

  1. Sex.
  2. Sexual orientation.
  3. Race, including colour, nationality, ethnic or national  origin.
  4. Being or becoming transsexual.
  5. Age.
  6. Disability.
  7. Being pregnant of having a child.
  8. Being married or in a civil partnership.
  9. Religion, belief or lack of religion/belief
You’re protected from discrimination in these situations:
  1. at work
  2. in education
  3. as a consumer
  4. when using public services
  5. when buying or renting property
  6. as a member or guest of a private club or association
We believe that the women of North Lancashire are being discriminated against due to their sex when using public services.

The Trust says it's flexing, not discrimination,  but we'd like to change male and female for a few other protected characteristics to make our point.  How about...

There are more heterosexuals needing beds than homosexuals, so we will only treat heterosexual patients at The Orchard. All beds will be made for heterosexual use only and all homosexual patients will be sent out of the area.

There are more White British needing beds than Asian British, so we will only treat White British patients at The Orchard. All beds will be made for White British use only and all Asian British patients will be sent out of the area.

There are more young people needing beds than older people, so we will only treat young patients at The Orchard. All beds will be made for use by young people only and all older people will be sent out of the area.

It sounds so wrong doesn't it.  So why is THIS acceptable?

There are more men needing beds than women, so we will only treat men at The Orchard.  All beds will be made for male use only and all female patients will be sent out of the area.

Thursday, 6 November 2014

Temporary or not, this is a closure that should never have happened

We do wonder whether Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust is feeling more secure now. 

They have told us publicly that it’s a temporary move that won’t last for weeks and weeks.  That it’s to cope with a peak in demand for male beds, that of course has nothing to do with them closing 15 of them elsewhere in the county.  And they’ve publicly stated that it’s not having a negative impact despite the women telling them that it is.

In their eyes this is surely a non-story now.  It’s a temporary peak in demand with no impact.  Our campaign is just an overreaction by a group of women to a perfectly rational and sensible decision by the Trust. 

Now where have we heard that kind of thing before?

Women!  You are overreacting to us putting the needs of male service users before yours!
Women!  You are overreacting with your anxiety at being treated away from your homes and families!
Women!  You just don’t understand how these things work, so do go ahead and STFU now won’t you!

Well, we’re not going to shut up.

Temporary or not, the closure should never have happened.  Temporary or not, the needs of male service users are not more important than female service users.  Temporary or not, the worry and anxiety felt by the women is real and harmful. Temporary or not, the costs incurred by families to visit their relatives are real and harmful.  Temporary or not, the emotional distress of the families is real and harmful.

Temporary or not, denying women access to local inpatient care is harmful, discriminatory and should never have happened in the first place.

Temporary doesn't make it better.

Wednesday, 5 November 2014

Parity of Care - Why closing local inpatient beds discriminates against women.

There are many reasons why we at Beds in the Orchard are campaigning for local inpatient care for the women of North Lancashire.  We've covered these in some of our previous posts.  Isolation, financial cost, disruption, distress for both the service user and their families.  Children separated from their parents.  Women separated from their families.   All with no chance of being returned to their local area.

When a section 3 can see you detained in hospital for 6 months, its glaringly obvious why being away from home for that long can have long lasting and negative effects for the women being treated.

But is this really discrimination?

The Trust tell us that this is due to "A peak in demand for male beds".  Lets apply that to something else.

If there was a peak in demand for school places for boys, a school would not just take male pupils, they would also take female pupils, with both boys and girls having to go to other schools if there wasn't a place.

If there was a peak in demand for emergency care due to men having accidents, an A&E department wouldn't just treat men and send the women to a different area.

If there was a peak in demand with more men needing cardiac care than women needing cardiac care, a hospital wouldn't only treat men and send women out of the area.

So why is it acceptable when there are more men requiring psychiatric care than women, to only treat the men and send women out of the area?

Our position at Beds In the Orchard is that it is not acceptable at all.

Sunday, 2 November 2014

Clare's Story - A near miss, distressed children and a fear for the future.



 In April 2014, I was assessed in A&E under the Mental Health Act.  I’d been depressed for a long time, but the descent was long and slow, until it reached the point where making plans seemed like a perfectly rational thing to do.  Fortunately I had a good friend who knew it was absolutely not a rational thing to do, so she took me A&E with me protesting all the time that no one would believe it and it was a waste of time.

After being assessed by the MH liaison nurse, I was asked if I would go into hospital, but the only bed available was at The Priory in Manchester, a private hospital well over an hour’s drive from where I lived.  I refused as I didn’t want to be so far away from home with no possessions and no means of my husband getting there, as he had our two small children to look after.  In the end they decided not to detain me, but pass me over to the care of the local Crisis Team.

Like Crisis Teams all over the country, they are massively overstretched and a decision was taken to leave me in the care of the community team as I was seeing my psychiatrist the following afternoon.  By mid-morning the following day, I was waiting on the platform of the station for the London express train, however, the same good friend as the day before had sent her husband speculatively to see if I was there. That was the near miss.  If a local bed had been available the day before then I would’ve been in hospital, safe.

Thankfully this time there was a bed in Ridge Lea hospital in Lancaster and I was admitted and stayed there as an inpatient before the hospital was closed and all of the patients transferred to The Orchard, the new unit in Lancaster.  I was in hospital for around 3 months.

The impact of my admission on my family was enormous.  My son has autism and was extremely disrupted by my being away as it changed his routines.  His autism meant that couldn't express how he felt easily, so he got cross every day.  His home to school diary was filled with examples of him being upset by my absence and struggling in school.  My young daughter didn’t remember the last time I’d been admitted as she’d been too young, but this time she was very aware and her behaviour became very difficult as she struggled to come to terms with my being in hospital.  She became clingy to everyone else in the family and anxious that I would never come back.

The only thing that made it better for them was that I was still close by.  My husband bought them up nearly every day after school and nursery and we got to spend time together, even though at the time it took monumental effort for me to be ‘normal’ with them.  As I got better and had leave, I was able to go home to dinner, or do bedtime with them or all the small things that a parent does for a child.  Sometimes this was more for their benefit than for mine as mental illness takes away some of the person you are, but to them it meant everything.

If I had been at a hospital miles away, none of that would have been possible.  My children’s struggles would have been even harder.  The visits would be more sporadic with long journeys to get to see me and the impact of my absence would have been amplified many times over.  At the beginning, my only motivation to get through the day was the obligation I felt to see them.  As I got better, that changed to wanting to see them as I missed them, till eventually I was discharged.

Even when they are unwell; mothers need to be near their children and children need to have regular contact with their mothers.  Isolating me from my children would have caused distress on both sides, but now this is what would happen if I was admitted again. 

Getting ill again already scares me as it has had a huge and lasting impact on my life emotionally and financially and has shaken my whole world.  Now I have the additional fear that if I get ill, I will be taken away from my family, my friends and everyone who means anything to me.  I will be ill, alone and isolated from the very people I need to support me to get well.

Closing The Orchard to women like me, may mean more near misses like mine as they are too scared to take help knowing they will be sent away.  Speaking to other women in the community, I know I am not alone.  Fear when you already have a mental illness is not good.  Not good at all.

The full article published today on Everyday Victim Blaming

For those of you who haven't seen the article published today on Everyday Victim Blaming, I'm sharing it below, in full.



Lancashire Care NHS Trust delivers a stark example of Victim Blaming and delivers changes that maximise the distress of vulnerable women in its care.

In October 2014, The Orchard Psychiatric unit in Lancaster was closed to women.  This change was made without consultation with service users or the wider community and the result is that any woman in Lancaster and its surrounding towns and villages will no longer be able to access local inpatient psychiatric care. 

The closest psychiatric hospital with female beds is in Blackpool, a 50 minute drive from Lancaster.  Women will also be sent to Blackburn, Burnley, Chorley and as far as Manchester and beyond.  The shortage of psychiatric beds in the Lancashire Care NHS Trust has always meant that patients could be sent to hospitals out of their area, but moved back into the area once a bed became available.  Now there are no female inpatient beds in Lancaster, seriously ill women from that area will be separated from their families, friends and support networks at a time when they are most in need of that support.

While information about why the closure was made is sparse, due to the lack of a consultation process, there have been two reasons given by the trust for this decision.  Firstly, it is to help protect vulnerable women and secondly, because there is a greater demand for male beds.  The first of these reasons falls under Victim Blaming and the second is gender discrimination as the trust prioritises the needs of men over women. 

Need for Beds?
Before this move, the Lancashire Care NHS Trust already held more male than female beds across the trust.  Information about numbers can be found on their website - http://www.lancashirecare.nhs.uk/Services/Adult-Mental-Health/Inpatient-Care.php. 

The Orchard had 10 Male and 8 Female beds.  Occupation rates in the Female area ran at 100%, with beds being filled the same day, and in some cases just hours after a patient was discharged.  There were frequent occasions where a female bed would be used temporarily for another woman, while the patient it belonged to was on home leave or at the general hospital in order to cope with demand. 

There is a definite need for female beds in the area, so why is the demand for male beds more important than local psychiatric care for women?

If lack of male beds is an issue then that should be addressed by the trust by looking to increase the number of male beds without denying access to a whole group of people under their care.  Women should not be denied local access to inpatient psychiatric care due to a lack of male beds.  The needs of women with mental illness are not less important than the needs of men.  The need of women to be close to their families, children and support networks is not less important than male beds. 

Victim Blaming and Maximising distress

The suggestion that the move to make The Orchard a single sex ward is to protect vulnerable women seems to be a clear case of Victim Blaming as instead of addressing the problem of male aggression, it is blaming women for their vulnerability.  It says to women "You may be vulnerable, so to protect you, we are going to deny you access to local inpatient care."

Before the closure there were 10 male beds and 8 female beds in the unit.  The male and female areas were separate and could only be entered via key-card access, so the men and women could only access their own bed areas.  Individual rooms in the unit were also locked via key-card, providing extra security.  A single sex lounge was available in both the male and female areas of the ward.  In addition to these areas, there were communal areas, including a dining room, games room, lounge and inner courtyard.  In the other hospitals of the trust, Chorley operates a similar system with single sex and communal areas and Ormskirk has a fully mixed ward.  This would suggest that there are reasons other than vulnerability for denying women access to The Orchard.

Rather than protecting vulnerable women, removing local inpatient care will increase their vulnerability and significantly increase their distress.  Sending women 30-70 miles away from their home for treatment means that they won't have access to their families, friends or support networks.  Research on isolating women from their support networks is well documented as having negative effects.  Women are also still overwhelmingly the primary care givers to children and carers for older adults.  Treating women 30+ miles from their home means less opportunities for contact with their children and people they care for, causing distress on both sides.

If there has been a problem with male to female aggression in the communal areas, then the trust should address how that is managed.  There are single sex units available for men who are seriously ill, and therefore at risk of harming others and otherwise aggressive males.  A better solution would be for staff to ensure that known aggressors or those shown to be aggressive are moved to male wards, able to deal with those problems, rather than place the blame on women's vulnerability and deny them access to the local services that they need.

Removing access to local care is likely to discourage women from seeking help and accepting voluntary admission, and will discourage their families from seeking help for their relatives, knowing they will be sent miles away from home.  This can lead to increased detentions under the Mental Health act, with women not willing to accept voluntary admission, or by deteriorating to the point where a section is inevitable.

This closure leaves the women of Lancaster and the surrounding areas with stark choices.  Should they accept treatment for their mental illness isolated away from home, or stay with the support of their families and friends, knowing that they may be detained against their will anyway?

Either way, the decision of the trust to close the female beds at The Orchard is likely to have significant negative consequences for the women and their families.



Orchard Beds Campaign is published in Everyday Victim Blaming!

http://everydayvictimblaming.com/discussions/lancashire-care-nhs-trust-delivers-a-stark-example-of-victim-blaming/

Please help us get female inpatient care back for the women of Lancaster and district.  Contacts and addresses below.

If you tweet - tweet @lancashirecare.

Saturday, 1 November 2014

Closing female beds punishes women and families on low incomes

The closure of female inpatient care at The Orchard has a disproportionate effect on women and families on low incomes. It restricts the ability of families and friends to visit and leaves them with stark choices.  Do they visit their loved one, sacrificing other things that they need, or do they stay away?

Visiting people has significant costs in terms of time and money.  Lets take Blackpool as an example.  To get to visit someone by local transport, you will need the return train ticket from Lancaster to Blackpool North stations, then bus fares to and from Lancaster Station and between Blackpool North and Parkwood Hospital.

Single Adult Visiting
Train, Adult Day Return £14.50.  Journey time 1h11m each way, (variable time to change trains).
Bus, Lancashire Day Rider (cheapest option) £7.20.  Journey times between 30 mins - 1 hour each way.

Total Cost  £21.40 return
Journey Time - Between 3h22m and 4h22.mins return.

Adult visiting with two children.
Train: One adult and two children  £29.00
Bus, Family Day Rider (cheapest option) £16.50  Journey times between 30 mins - 1 hour each way.
Total Cost £45.50

If you factor in the length of your visit, then a trip to see a loved one will take up to 6 hours in journey and visiting time.That is a day off work, or a very long trip for small children in particular.  For many families, £45.50 is money that they would struggle to find and certainly would result in less visits, or in some cases any visits at all.  This has a negative impact for all involved.

While people who have access to a car, may be able to reach the hospitals more easily, there is still a cost in petrol and parking and still a cost of time taken.

Women who are in low income families are disproportionally affected by the removal of local beds, both financially and emotionally as they are less able to see their families, friends and access other local support.


Friday, 31 October 2014

Is 'Based on Need' a self-fulfilling prophecy?

A source close to the trust revealed today that the decision to close the female inpatient beds was based on a need for more male beds.

We know that there is a high demand for female beds, with women already being sent out of the area, often to Private Hospitals, such as The Priory in Manchester due to lack of capacity and a FOI request has already been sent to the Lancashire Care Trust about the number of female admissions.  Even without this information there are questions that have to be asked about this statement.

Firstly, why are there not enough male beds?  It is the responsibility of the Trust to ensure there is some slack in the system, but the planned cuts of 25% to the services provided by this trust in the coming year would suggest that inpatient care is not being covered properly.

Secondly, this looks strongly like discrimination based on sex.  Why should women be denied local access to inpatient psychiatric care due to a lack of male beds?  Are the needs of women with mental illness less important than the needs of men?  Are the needs of women to be close to their families, children and support networks less important than the needs of the men?

Moreover, is the damage caused to female inpatients by removing them from the local area, less important than providing 8 beds for male patients?   I would suggest it isn't.

This brings me onto the point of this post.  If you reduce the number of female beds, it will reduce the number of admissions, skewing the assessment of 'need'. The closure of the female inpatient service in Lancaster will also...

a. Discourage women from accepting voluntary admission, reducing the number demanding a bed.
b. Discourage women from seeking help knowing that they will be sent long distances from home, reducing the demand for a bed.
c. Discourage families from seeking help for their female relatives, knowing they will be sent away from home.

The need for local female psychiatric inpatient care is as important as the need for male beds.  Reducing access is a self-fulfilling prophecy.