Showing posts with label judicial review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label judicial review. Show all posts

Tuesday, 9 December 2014

Judicial Review - you win some, you lose some.

Today we had some bad news regarding our taking the Trust to court for Judicial Review.

The rules for Judicial Review state that the claim has to be brought within 3 months of the decision being made.

Recent information provided to us states that the decision was made in August and unfortunately that means we have missed the window of opportunity by a few weeks.

While we're obviously disappointed by this, we still send our thanks to Irwin Mitchell and Partners in Manchester who spoke to us about the case and gave us a lot of advice for free.

While it is incredibly frustrating that we can't take the more formal channel of action on this occasion, we are not wholly disappointed.  We still showed that the Trust was unable to supply any documentation about due regard to the Equality Act 2010 when asked.

You win some, you lose some, but we shall carry on.

Wednesday, 3 December 2014

Judicial Review - Letter Before Claim to be sent to the LCFT

After taking advice yesterday, Beds in the Orchard contacted their solicitor and asked for a Letter Before Claim to be sent to the Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust with regards to taking them to court for a Judicial Review into their action of closing The Orchard to women.

When taking action, even temporary, that has a direct affect on a Protected Characteristic as outlined in the Equality Act of 2010, in this case a person's sex, a public body must pay due regard to the act and must publish documentation about how due regard was given when asked. The Trust as unable to provide such information and are therefore liable to Judicial Review.


Below are some of the questions that have been asked amongst campaigners and our responses.

What does this mean?
The Letter Before Claim will lay out the case for how the Trust has made a decision in a way that contravenes the Equality Act.  It will give them the opportunity to negotiate a resolution with our campaign before it goes to court.

Sounds expensive.
Judicial Review claims are eligible for Legal Aid.  For someone to be eligible for Legal Aid they need to be in receipt of certain benefits - in our case ESA, have savings of less than 8K and less than 100k of equity in any property they own.  Because of the nature of the people we are supporting, there are a number of our group who qualify for Legal Aid.

Do you really want to go to court?
This campaign has always been about returning inpatient care to the women of North Lancashire and that is all we want.  We would naturally prefer to do this out of court so that the public money that funds the NHS was spent on patient care rather than court cases.  

What next?
We would appeal to the LCFT to find a way to return The Orchard to a mixed sex facility as soon as possible and to not close the facility to women again.  We are still at a stage where we can resolve this together and as our case is quite clear cut it would benefit no one for this to be taken fully down the legal route.

Thursday, 6 November 2014

Is the decision to close the Unit to women vulnerable to a judicial review?

One of our supporters thinks this may be the case, as they raise it in a letter to Heather Tierney-Moore, Chief Exec of Lancashire Care NHS Trust.  The full letter is below.

Ms Heather Tierney-Moore, Chief Executive,
Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust,
Sceptre Point,
Sceptre Way, Walton Summit,
Preston,
PR5 6AW

Dear Ms Tierney-Moore

Re The Orchard Unit

I do not make a habit of writing to complete strangers at the other end of the country to complain, but I am writing at the prompting of my sister. She has been a patient on several occasions in the old Ridge Lea Hospital and may well need a bed in the future.

As I understand it, the new Orchard Unit has been made exclusively male suddenly and without consulting with the public or service users. If so, I would note that this decision is of dubious legality and may be vulnerable to judicial review.

The account given is that there is a pressing need for beds for male patients and women are being excluded on the grounds that they are vulnerable to the male patients in such an environment. If this is so then I believe that the decision is entirely the wrong way round; the vulnerable patients need to be protected and if, in an extreme case, the men (in general) are liable to prey on women then it is the issue of the male patients that needs to be addressed. To exclude women is to punish the vulnerable, surely?

There is clearly a need for more beds for the mentally ill in the Preston Area as there is such competition for the beds and maybe the closure of Ridge Lea should have been preceded by an analysis of future needs and the level of peak demand (NOT average demand, as this will always fall well short of actual need). I can appreciate that in an era of budget pressures (and when were there not such pressures?) providing beds is always difficult, but I believe the recent political statements reveal by the targets being introduced for mental health treatment, there is more political will to improve mental health treatment than for many years. It surely ill behoves a chief executive to follow a policy that seemingly reduces the capacity let alone the quality of care. I believe it may well be that The Orchard Unit needs a companion unit for female patients and probably larger and preferably in advance of provision for male patients.

I worked as a chief officer in the Probation Service for many years. My experience is that men do not present with as many mental health issues as women but they have almost an exclusive hold on severe personality disorders. If the rise in male patient numbers is in any way a reflection of this I would strongly suggest that they are not amenable to treatment, that they will remain in your care for as long as they can manage it to avoid the courts/prisons and will likely pose a major threat to staff, other patients and themselves. It is not sensible, in my view, to have such people in contact with the generally mentally ill, and especially if those mentally ill people are in any way vulnerable (which they surely would be) and women.

I look forward to your comments.