This is a quick summary of the main points made in this blog with links to the relevant posts.
In his interview with BBC Radio Lancashire, Keith Dibble, Deputy Network Director of LCFT was asked "Do you accept that moving these women further away from their families and children could be damaging?" He replied "We believe not".
Well we are telling you that it is damaging, Keith. We believe removing all local inpatient care for the women of Lancaster and the surrounding area is wrong and damaging because...
It discriminates against women.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/the-equality-act-2010-how-is-this-not.html
It punishes women and families on low incomes.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/closing-female-beds-punishes-women-and.html
It can lead to increased detentions under the Mental Health Act.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/10/can-closure-of-female-inpatient.html
It deters women from seeking, or accepting help.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/10/is-based-on-need-self-fulfilling.html
It affects families and children.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/away-from-family-and-early-release.html
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/so-i-asked-my-children-what-was-it-like.html
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/clares-story-near-miss-distressed.html
It damages women by isolating them from their support networks.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/the-full-article-published-today-on.html
And lets not forget that even some LCFT Staff agree with us.
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/views-of-worker-in-lancashire-care-nhs.html
How wrong does something have to be before Lancashire Care NHS Trust will change it?
Saturday, 8 November 2014
The Equality Act 2010 - How is this not discrimination?
The Equality Act of 2010 sets out a list of Protected Characteristics. These are: (in no particular order)
The Trust says it's flexing, not discrimination, but we'd like to change male and female for a few other protected characteristics to make our point. How about...
There are more heterosexuals needing beds than homosexuals, so we will only treat heterosexual patients at The Orchard. All beds will be made for heterosexual use only and all homosexual patients will be sent out of the area.
There are more White British needing beds than Asian British, so we will only treat White British patients at The Orchard. All beds will be made for White British use only and all Asian British patients will be sent out of the area.
There are more young people needing beds than older people, so we will only treat young patients at The Orchard. All beds will be made for use by young people only and all older people will be sent out of the area.
It sounds so wrong doesn't it. So why is THIS acceptable?
There are more men needing beds than women, so we will only treat men at The Orchard. All beds will be made for male use only and all female patients will be sent out of the area.
- Sex.
- Sexual orientation.
- Race, including colour, nationality, ethnic or national origin.
- Being or becoming transsexual.
- Age.
- Disability.
- Being pregnant of having a child.
- Being married or in a civil partnership.
- Religion, belief or lack of religion/belief
- at work
- in education
- as a consumer
- when using public services
- when buying or renting property
- as a member or guest of a private club or association
The Trust says it's flexing, not discrimination, but we'd like to change male and female for a few other protected characteristics to make our point. How about...
There are more heterosexuals needing beds than homosexuals, so we will only treat heterosexual patients at The Orchard. All beds will be made for heterosexual use only and all homosexual patients will be sent out of the area.
There are more White British needing beds than Asian British, so we will only treat White British patients at The Orchard. All beds will be made for White British use only and all Asian British patients will be sent out of the area.
There are more young people needing beds than older people, so we will only treat young patients at The Orchard. All beds will be made for use by young people only and all older people will be sent out of the area.
It sounds so wrong doesn't it. So why is THIS acceptable?
There are more men needing beds than women, so we will only treat men at The Orchard. All beds will be made for male use only and all female patients will be sent out of the area.
Top 5 Reasons People Don't Share Their Stories on the Blog
Almost all of the work on this blog and on twitter is being done by a small group of people, with a much wider group of people supporting us.
We've had 3 - soon to be 4 contributions from local service users about their treatment and what being treated locally means to them and two anonymous contributions from people working in the trust.
Here are the top 5 reasons for not contributing, in ascending order.
5. Someone in my family works for the Trust and I'm scared they will lose their job.
4. Nothing will happen so what's the point? The Trust doesn't care about us, just money.
3. I'm just too ill to deal with this right now. I want to help, but I just can't.
2.I'm scared that if I share my story, someone will read it and know it's me. I don't want people to know I've been to Ridge Lea.
1. I'm scared that even if we DO get the beds back, if they know I'm involved, next time I'm ill, they'll send me away to punish me for speaking out.
So that's fear if being punished, fear of being judged for having a mental illness, fear for your family, despondency and illness.
Thank goodness some of us are able to stand up for those who want to, but can't.
We've had 3 - soon to be 4 contributions from local service users about their treatment and what being treated locally means to them and two anonymous contributions from people working in the trust.
Here are the top 5 reasons for not contributing, in ascending order.
5. Someone in my family works for the Trust and I'm scared they will lose their job.
4. Nothing will happen so what's the point? The Trust doesn't care about us, just money.
3. I'm just too ill to deal with this right now. I want to help, but I just can't.
2.I'm scared that if I share my story, someone will read it and know it's me. I don't want people to know I've been to Ridge Lea.
1. I'm scared that even if we DO get the beds back, if they know I'm involved, next time I'm ill, they'll send me away to punish me for speaking out.
So that's fear if being punished, fear of being judged for having a mental illness, fear for your family, despondency and illness.
Thank goodness some of us are able to stand up for those who want to, but can't.
Friday, 7 November 2014
The care at The Orchard - Claire shares her thoughts.
This blog so far has focused on the Lancashire Care NHS Trust and how they are hurting the women they are supposed to care for.
We would like to make clear that the campaign is not against the staff at The Orchard and we’d like to spend a few moments focusing on the care provided by them when you are acutely unwell. Claire shares her thoughts again.
Earlier this year I was admitted to Ridge Lea hospital and then transferred to The Orchard when that hospital closed. My full story is here - http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/clares-story-near-miss-distressed.html
The Orchard is staffed by a dedicated team of qualified nurses, nursing assistants, occupational therapists, pharmacists, admin staff, doctors and a consultant psychiatrist with a penchant for Cadbury's chocolate. While I was at the Orchard, I was always impressed by the care and compassion they showed to the service users they were looking after; sometimes under very difficult circumstances.
Whether it was the OTs getting people involved with ‘Wake up and Stretch’, when many preferred ‘Sit down and Smoke’, the nurses taking the time to talk with you despite being snowed under by paperwork, or the nursing assistants taking the time throughout the day and night to make sure that you were OK and had everything you needed, not one made you feel that you were a burden or alone.
Everyone was treated with dignity, everyone was treated according to their needs and no one was left to fend for themselves. A great comfort when you are acutely unwell.
I am not saying that everything was perfect. It was clear that many of the nursing staff would have loved to have more time to spend with the patients, if it wasn’t for the reams of admin they were expected to do every day. Sometimes there was only one qualified member of staff on duty, which was a concern and sometimes communication about appointments was hit and miss, making you feel out of control, but the important thing was that the actual caring was always present. The level of care was consistent, even with the staff working long 12 hour days. You would expect that things would slip by the end of one of their mammoth shifts, but it never did and for that alone, they deserve praise.
There were some things that made being at The Orchard unpleasant, the main issue being the food. This was a never ending stream of pre-prepared meals, shipped in and reheated on the premises, with nothing fresh at all apart from a bowl of fruit. Because the food was always heated in trays, specialities were crunchy rice, where the re-heating dried out the rice at the top, bottom and sides, leaving only the middle soft, and a seemingly never ending stream of quiche for the vegetarians - although they occasionally called it a tart or flan, it was pretty much the same thing. As someone who believes strongly that fresh food is important to health, whether mental or otherwise, it was hard to be somewhere there wasn’t even an oven in the kitchen.
However; the people who served the food were always kind and courteous, even when people like me were critical about what was on offer. The people who cleaned and looked after the building were also kind and courteous. No one made you feel awkward or ‘lesser’ for having a mental illness. For that I am grateful.
The environment at the Orchard was pleasant, although the outside space was disappointing after being in Ridge Lea Hospital where there had been large and pleasant grounds, with trees filled with blossom and wildlife running around. The rooms were well equipped, with a TV in each room – although the bizarre choice of channels did raise eyebrows. I didn’t meet a single service user who sat down to watch BBC Parliament in the whole time I was there.
There is a café that served fresh (oh joy!) sandwiches and decent coffee, with staff who could always be relied on to cheer you up. It was clear that they all loved their jobs and in turn that made the café a very pleasant place to be. It provided a much welcome rest from being in the ward, and an opportunity to talk to the volunteers; ex-service users themselves, who spent time listening to your issues and helping advocate for you with any complaints or compliments you wanted to pass on.
All of the staff at The Orchard and The Apple Tree Café worked hard to help people get well and supported them through really difficult times. I am grateful for the care they gave me when I was unwell and I hope that people reading this will appreciate the good work they do too.
We would like to make clear that the campaign is not against the staff at The Orchard and we’d like to spend a few moments focusing on the care provided by them when you are acutely unwell. Claire shares her thoughts again.
Earlier this year I was admitted to Ridge Lea hospital and then transferred to The Orchard when that hospital closed. My full story is here - http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/clares-story-near-miss-distressed.html
The Orchard is staffed by a dedicated team of qualified nurses, nursing assistants, occupational therapists, pharmacists, admin staff, doctors and a consultant psychiatrist with a penchant for Cadbury's chocolate. While I was at the Orchard, I was always impressed by the care and compassion they showed to the service users they were looking after; sometimes under very difficult circumstances.
Whether it was the OTs getting people involved with ‘Wake up and Stretch’, when many preferred ‘Sit down and Smoke’, the nurses taking the time to talk with you despite being snowed under by paperwork, or the nursing assistants taking the time throughout the day and night to make sure that you were OK and had everything you needed, not one made you feel that you were a burden or alone.
Everyone was treated with dignity, everyone was treated according to their needs and no one was left to fend for themselves. A great comfort when you are acutely unwell.
I am not saying that everything was perfect. It was clear that many of the nursing staff would have loved to have more time to spend with the patients, if it wasn’t for the reams of admin they were expected to do every day. Sometimes there was only one qualified member of staff on duty, which was a concern and sometimes communication about appointments was hit and miss, making you feel out of control, but the important thing was that the actual caring was always present. The level of care was consistent, even with the staff working long 12 hour days. You would expect that things would slip by the end of one of their mammoth shifts, but it never did and for that alone, they deserve praise.
There were some things that made being at The Orchard unpleasant, the main issue being the food. This was a never ending stream of pre-prepared meals, shipped in and reheated on the premises, with nothing fresh at all apart from a bowl of fruit. Because the food was always heated in trays, specialities were crunchy rice, where the re-heating dried out the rice at the top, bottom and sides, leaving only the middle soft, and a seemingly never ending stream of quiche for the vegetarians - although they occasionally called it a tart or flan, it was pretty much the same thing. As someone who believes strongly that fresh food is important to health, whether mental or otherwise, it was hard to be somewhere there wasn’t even an oven in the kitchen.
However; the people who served the food were always kind and courteous, even when people like me were critical about what was on offer. The people who cleaned and looked after the building were also kind and courteous. No one made you feel awkward or ‘lesser’ for having a mental illness. For that I am grateful.
The environment at the Orchard was pleasant, although the outside space was disappointing after being in Ridge Lea Hospital where there had been large and pleasant grounds, with trees filled with blossom and wildlife running around. The rooms were well equipped, with a TV in each room – although the bizarre choice of channels did raise eyebrows. I didn’t meet a single service user who sat down to watch BBC Parliament in the whole time I was there.
There is a café that served fresh (oh joy!) sandwiches and decent coffee, with staff who could always be relied on to cheer you up. It was clear that they all loved their jobs and in turn that made the café a very pleasant place to be. It provided a much welcome rest from being in the ward, and an opportunity to talk to the volunteers; ex-service users themselves, who spent time listening to your issues and helping advocate for you with any complaints or compliments you wanted to pass on.
All of the staff at The Orchard and The Apple Tree Café worked hard to help people get well and supported them through really difficult times. I am grateful for the care they gave me when I was unwell and I hope that people reading this will appreciate the good work they do too.
A letter from a worker in the Trust
Again we receive an anonymous email from someone at The Trust, again we have no idea who this is from, but have sent our thanks. "BananaJam" shares their thoughts.
[Edit - While we really appreciate messages from the trust, we really don't want to get people in trouble!]
I am following your blog with interest.
Following local news, This is Trust wide knowledge, and County wide is public knowledge. It has filtered down through the grapevine that staff at the Orchard have been given a "talking to" to say nothing to anyone even inside the trust.
I work for LCFT.
What are senior management afraid of in this campaign. The truth is the truth. Public knowledge of Truth AND Lies is essential, especially in public sector services. If a health service is so afraid of a simple truth (truth already in the public domain) that it feels the need to order staff to keep silent, the question has to be begged, why?!
Nothing said to date that I am aware of has been anything other than public knowledge. By it's very nature, the whole issue being campaigned for is public knowledge.
Women, take heart, many of us working within the Trust are behind you! Women and Men. Many people are discussing it within the general public too. In the last week, I have heard people talking about it in my local town.
You have strong cross-gender support for an story that clearly has a major gender thread, in a subject area of Health and Wellbeing.
[Edit - While we really appreciate messages from the trust, we really don't want to get people in trouble!]
I am following your blog with interest.
Following local news, This is Trust wide knowledge, and County wide is public knowledge. It has filtered down through the grapevine that staff at the Orchard have been given a "talking to" to say nothing to anyone even inside the trust.
I work for LCFT.
What are senior management afraid of in this campaign. The truth is the truth. Public knowledge of Truth AND Lies is essential, especially in public sector services. If a health service is so afraid of a simple truth (truth already in the public domain) that it feels the need to order staff to keep silent, the question has to be begged, why?!
Nothing said to date that I am aware of has been anything other than public knowledge. By it's very nature, the whole issue being campaigned for is public knowledge.
Women, take heart, many of us working within the Trust are behind you! Women and Men. Many people are discussing it within the general public too. In the last week, I have heard people talking about it in my local town.
You have strong cross-gender support for an story that clearly has a major gender thread, in a subject area of Health and Wellbeing.
This is a campaign for fairness
The Beds in the
Orchard campaign is run by a group of local service users, both male and
female. We are campaigning for the fair
treatment of women in our area. Our position is that both men and women should
have access to local inpatient psychiatric care. That both groups have equal rights to local
inpatient care and that sending all of one group out of the area is
discriminatory.
North Lancashire; the area surrounding, Lancaster has been
served by a mixed sex ward since c2008 when the Lancaster Unit opened at Ridge
Lea hospital, in Lancaster. Before then, there was a mix of provision in Lancaster, including both male and female wards.
The Lancaster Unit had 17 beds, and throughout it's service, all 17 beds were used by a mix of men and women. 10 beds were used for men, and 7 were used
for women. At no point was the Lancaster Unit
made male only, or female only. Both
sexes had the opportunity for local inpatient care.
In June, the Lancaster Unit at Ridge Lea was closed and the
service users were all moved into a new unit – The Orchard in Lancaster. The Orchard was a unit for anyone with an
acute mental illness from age 18 onwards (no upper limit) and also including
people with learning disabilities.
At the Orchard there were 10 male beds, but now only 6
female beds. There were two swing beds
that could go from male to female, so they became female at that time to
accommodate the 7 women who had been transferred from Ridge Lea. Another woman was admitted, so the totals
were 10 male and 8 female beds. When
there is a peak in demand, The Orchard can swing the two beds back to male,
giving them 12 male beds and 6 female beds.
Treatment under Lancashire Care NHS Trust is ‘county-wide’. This means that if there isn’t a bed in your
local unit, you can be sent anywhere else in the county where there is a
bed. When a bed became available in your
local unit, you would be transferred closer to home. Beds in the Orchard has never said or implied
this is not the case. However;
There has always been
inpatient provision for the women of North Lancashire either at Ridge Lea or
The Orchard. So there has always been the opportunity to be treated close to home.
We are campaigning, because in Oct 2014, the NHS Trust didn’t
‘swing’ the two beds at The Orchard, they closed the whole unit completely to women, creating
an 18 bed male unit. This means that all women from our area are transferred
to hospitals a significant distance away with no chance of local care, for the first time ever.
The Trust say that it is due to a Peak in Demand for male beds, however such a peak in demand has
never resulted in completely removing services to either men or women before and it come after them closing 15 male beds elsewhere in the county.
The Trust said in a Radio Interview on Monday 4th
November that there had been a peak in demand for female beds earlier this year
and now there was a peak in demand for male beds, but when the peak in demand
for female beds happened they did not reduce the number of male beds in Lancaster or
close The Orchard and make it women only, and women were sent as far away as Manchester for treatment. They kept the 10 male beds in both units.
We at Beds in the Orchard are the family and friends. We are the service users it is affecting. We want inpatient care for men and women and for one group not to be denied local care because of their sex.
Thursday, 6 November 2014
It's all the fault of those long dark nights - Lancaster Guardian
There has been a peak in demand for male psychiatric hospital stays
in Lancashire due to “darker and longer nights” and financial worries in
the run up to Christmas.
http://www.lancasterguardian.co.uk/news/health/local/longer-nights-cause-peak-in-hospital-stays-1-6937360
So says the trust.
This suggests that this is a known phenomenon. That male service users are more likely to be admitted in Autumn when the nights get longer and the run up to Christmas gives them financial worries.
If this is a known phenomenon, then again I have to question why the Trust closed 15 male beds at the start of the autumn. Why close beds, knowing that you would have a peak in demand?
Why not ask them yourself on @LancashireCare or customer.care@lancashirecare@nhs.co.uk
They also say
“Temporary, short term changes are not subject to formal consultation to enable the trust to respond accordingly to the changing needs of a locality quickly. “The Trust’s new facilities have been designed with this in mind and feature ‘swing beds’ so that the ratio of male/female beds can be altered in line with demand, which is an ever changing scenario.
There are indeed swing beds at The Orchard, but the Trust hasn't swung just those beds, it closed the whole of the female ward and made it male only.
It is important to note that there has not been a reduction in the number of available female beds in Lancashire due to this temporary change; there are in fact empty female beds.”
That's not the point. The point is that there are no female beds at all in The Orchard meaning that all women from the area are treated long distances from where they live.
Empty beds elsewhere in the trust doesn't mean that it's acceptable to deny all women from the Lancaster area local inpatient care. It doesn't mitigate the negative effects from being treated away from home for long periods of time.
We know that women have been sent out of area, so we know there is a need for local beds.
The Trust seem to be spectacularly missing the point.
http://www.lancasterguardian.co.uk/news/health/local/longer-nights-cause-peak-in-hospital-stays-1-6937360
So says the trust.
This suggests that this is a known phenomenon. That male service users are more likely to be admitted in Autumn when the nights get longer and the run up to Christmas gives them financial worries.
If this is a known phenomenon, then again I have to question why the Trust closed 15 male beds at the start of the autumn. Why close beds, knowing that you would have a peak in demand?
Why not ask them yourself on @LancashireCare or customer.care@lancashirecare@nhs.co.uk
They also say
“Temporary, short term changes are not subject to formal consultation to enable the trust to respond accordingly to the changing needs of a locality quickly. “The Trust’s new facilities have been designed with this in mind and feature ‘swing beds’ so that the ratio of male/female beds can be altered in line with demand, which is an ever changing scenario.
There are indeed swing beds at The Orchard, but the Trust hasn't swung just those beds, it closed the whole of the female ward and made it male only.
It is important to note that there has not been a reduction in the number of available female beds in Lancashire due to this temporary change; there are in fact empty female beds.”
That's not the point. The point is that there are no female beds at all in The Orchard meaning that all women from the area are treated long distances from where they live.
Empty beds elsewhere in the trust doesn't mean that it's acceptable to deny all women from the Lancaster area local inpatient care. It doesn't mitigate the negative effects from being treated away from home for long periods of time.
We know that women have been sent out of area, so we know there is a need for local beds.
The Trust seem to be spectacularly missing the point.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)