We've spent this evening going over Claire's interview on BBC Radio Lancashire and the response to our campaign from Keith Dibble, the Deputy Director of the Lancashire Care NHS Trust.
We were going to post a long reply, but can actually summarise quite swiftly.
The County
There were a number of mentions by Keith about the County, for example "Balance across the county" and "Cross county requirement".
If there is a cross county requirement then removing 15 male beds will have changed the balance across the county of male beds.
We'll be submitting a FOI request about how many men from the Burnley area are being treated in the west and north of the county.
Home Treatment
Home treatment is indeed preferable. Sadly the crisis and home treatment teams are not augmented when beds are closed. Existing teams have an ever expanding case-load and less people are expected to look after more Service Users.
We doubt that when the male beds in Burnley were closed, the home treatment teams were expanded in that area and we doubt that when the female beds were closed in Lancaster that the home treatment teams were expanded in that area either.
Another Freedom of Information Request will be sent out tomorrow so we can confirm that to you.
(Our FOI person is going to have a busy day)
Clinical Priorities
Beds in the Orchard has never suggested that people requiring PICU care etc. should be treated at The Orchard. We all have personal experience of being unwell and know that some women need to be treated in specialist units.
However the women being sent away from Lancaster for treatment do not all need specialist treatment and they would benefit more from local care.
It appears that the trust position is that the Clinical Priorities are caring for the men of North Lancashire after the balance across the county was tipped by the closure of male beds.
Length of Closure
Keith stated that it is "Not the intention for this to run for weeks and weeks."
This goes against information we have been given, but will be pleased if this turns out to be correct. We will continue to campaign for the female beds at The Orchard to be reopened until provision for women is restored and also to ensure that this statement from the trust is upheld.
We will continue to actively publicise the closure of the beds by the Trust and we will be further investigating at the treatment of women in Mental Health Services run by the Lancashire Care NHS Trust.
Financial Reasons
Keith said there were no financial reasons for the closure of beds. However, since the Trust has to deliver a 25% cut in expenditure as directed by the Department of Health, we suspect that financial pressures may well be involved.
Tuesday, 4 November 2014
Beds In The Orchard, Trying to change things for the better.
At the moment, I'm listening to the Lancashire Care NHS Trust's spokesperson on BBC Lancashire Radio this morning, going through all of his points so I can fashion a response.
But I'm going to take a moment to share a quote with our readers.
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful individuals can change the world. Indeed, its the only thing that ever has."
Margaret Mead, US Anthropologist
That's us. A small group of individuals just trying to make things better for vulnerable women in North Lancashire. Here's to succeeding.
But I'm going to take a moment to share a quote with our readers.
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful individuals can change the world. Indeed, its the only thing that ever has."
Margaret Mead, US Anthropologist
That's us. A small group of individuals just trying to make things better for vulnerable women in North Lancashire. Here's to succeeding.
Lou's Story - Her concerns about being treated away from home.
Lou has been in contact with Beds In the Orchard to share her thoughts. Lou has been an inpatient on a number of occasions at Ridge Lea Hospital, close to home and also hospitals out of the area. Here's what she has to say.
I spent considerable time on the Halton Unit at Ridge Lea over 2 decades. My main concern following this was the fact that we were all in dormitories and how difficult that was in terms of whilst it was 'all women' we were all troubled and things for many of us were worse at night and some of us were also interacting with our voices during the night.
Despite all the wards being closed down at Ridge Lea over the last few years one positive about the opening of the Lancaster Unit at Ridge Lea was that people had their own room. I felt this would really facilitate peoples recovery.
I had in the past spent time on the psychiatric unit at Blackburn and also at Kendal. On both these occasions my psychosis was far more terrifying because I was in a different hospital and not where I lived.
I have tried to embrace the opening of the Orchards at Pathfinder Drive despite the lack of beds. However I heard this week that the ward has been made all male. I am extremely concerned about this based on my own experience of being admitted 'out of town'.
Issues of transport and visiting to outlying areas does not seem to have been considered.
Also I am not a mother myself but I believe women may struggle being out of town in terms of contact with their children.
I spent considerable time on the Halton Unit at Ridge Lea over 2 decades. My main concern following this was the fact that we were all in dormitories and how difficult that was in terms of whilst it was 'all women' we were all troubled and things for many of us were worse at night and some of us were also interacting with our voices during the night.
Despite all the wards being closed down at Ridge Lea over the last few years one positive about the opening of the Lancaster Unit at Ridge Lea was that people had their own room. I felt this would really facilitate peoples recovery.
I had in the past spent time on the psychiatric unit at Blackburn and also at Kendal. On both these occasions my psychosis was far more terrifying because I was in a different hospital and not where I lived.
I have tried to embrace the opening of the Orchards at Pathfinder Drive despite the lack of beds. However I heard this week that the ward has been made all male. I am extremely concerned about this based on my own experience of being admitted 'out of town'.
Issues of transport and visiting to outlying areas does not seem to have been considered.
Also I am not a mother myself but I believe women may struggle being out of town in terms of contact with their children.
Beds in the Orchard takes on the Trust on BBC Radio Lancashire
If you are from out of the county or just weren't awake at 7am this morning, you can listen again on their website - http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0293ql6. The podcast is available for 7 days from today.
Listen to Claire speaking on behalf of the Beds in the Orchard Campaign at around 7am and the response from Deputy Network Director of Lancashire Care NHS Trust at around 8am.
A lot of what Claire said is already on this blog. She's kicking herself slightly about missing some things out, but it was Live Radio and there was a lot to say in a small space of time.
A quick take on the Trusts response:
If this is 'county wide' care, then you really can't then argue that the closure of 15 male beds in the county wouldn't have an impact on the need for male beds in the county.
Travel expenses - If they have to be claimed back, then families without the money to pay up front will still be unable to visit their relatives.
We were delighted to hear that female beds will be open back in The Orchard 'as soon as possible'. We've heard you say that now, Lancashire Care. "As soon as possible" is NOT March 2015 when the Harbour is due to open.
This campaign will continue to run and will continue to apply pressure until the female beds are reinstated at the Orchard.
Listen to Claire speaking on behalf of the Beds in the Orchard Campaign at around 7am and the response from Deputy Network Director of Lancashire Care NHS Trust at around 8am.
A lot of what Claire said is already on this blog. She's kicking herself slightly about missing some things out, but it was Live Radio and there was a lot to say in a small space of time.
A quick take on the Trusts response:
If this is 'county wide' care, then you really can't then argue that the closure of 15 male beds in the county wouldn't have an impact on the need for male beds in the county.
Travel expenses - If they have to be claimed back, then families without the money to pay up front will still be unable to visit their relatives.
We were delighted to hear that female beds will be open back in The Orchard 'as soon as possible'. We've heard you say that now, Lancashire Care. "As soon as possible" is NOT March 2015 when the Harbour is due to open.
This campaign will continue to run and will continue to apply pressure until the female beds are reinstated at the Orchard.
Monday, 3 November 2014
Views of a worker in the Lancashire Care NHS Trust
I cannot thank enough the writer of this piece. Our campaign has been noticed by people who work in the trust and one person has been kind enough to share their thoughts. For good reason they wished to remain anonymous and as such we don't have details for them. We have mailed our heartfelt thanks to them for sending this to us tonight.
I am greatly troubled and
saddened by the closure of The Orchard Psychiatric Unit to women in Lancashire,
whether permanent or temporary. I am
incensed that this was executed without patient and carer consultation, but I
am in no way surprised.
The word is that this is
temporary until The Harbour the new 'flagship' hospital opens next year, yet
amazingly there was no need to stop women's access to the Orchard because until
a few weeks ago a full male ward of around 22 beds, was open and fully
functioning; Ward 18 in Burnley General Hospital. This should have remained
open until the 'Harbour' was open to accept this extra population of patients.
The reason for this process can
only be financial.
As a worker within this same
Trust, I see the effects upon patients, their carers, families, friends and
wider social networks of certain Trust policies. However; we must remember that Trust
Executives and Governors are duty bound to tow the line set by the Department
of Health, and this Government.
In other words the Trust Board,
it's Governors and high tier management are generally formulating policies
which in essence look purely at apparent immediate and short term financial
reductions not normally genuine economic benefit.
I have to question where the Duty
of Care has disappeared for both Trust Board members and the Department of
Health. The government quite rightly espouses duty of care, but acts like it
has no duty of care where short term finance is concerned. I believe Stafford was
also partly a result of 'Target' driven management which seriously affected
staff morale.
Government and Trust policies
often ignore true patient need; i.e. an excellent package of care, looking
specifically at an actual in depth holistic assessment of the patients and
families therapeutic needs; followed by a full and rigorous provision of the
identified therapeutic needs with fully trained staff at all levels.
I wonder whether people are aware that just 3 or 4 years back, the
Trust initiated it's DoH ordered programme of budget cuts by a fifth (20%). Within the last year I was
advised that this figure was increased to a quarter (25%). This programme had a
5 year time period.
What this means in real term reductions, someone smarter
than I will have to say. These cuts march on, contrary to the statement earlier
this year by David Cameron that NHS budgets are safe and 'Ring fenced'.
It should also be noted that in
the midst of this earlier 20% cut, the board approved and the Chief Executive
accepted a 20% RISE in her salary. This took her already incredible salary way
over £200,000. In my opinion, if someone
needs such a salary as an inducement to stay in post, I have to ask; does that
person have the right motive to be there?
Surely providing what is NEEDED
has to be the MOST economical way of caring for a person who is ill. I believe
especially so with mental illness. With physical brain lesions, we expect
everything to be thrown at brain Surgery; e.g. if a family member has a brain
tumour or has been involved in a fall; yet we give as little as possible
towards brain manipulation (Psychiatry / Psychology), where the affect is
functional. This is the same organ.
I feel duty bound to loudly state
that providing the necessary holistic and comprehensive person centred care
package is an imperative for all patients, their families/carers and the wider socio-economic setting. Common sense says
that this care package has to include ready access to a LOCAL inpatient unit
when hospitalisation is necessary.
People with Mental Illness are so
often sidelined, minimalised and misunderstood even by their own family. Not to mention their friends, fellow
colleagues, Workplace Management, and dare I say it, yes even a number of so
called Mental Health 'Professionals'. This ignorance affects their attitude and
therefore behaviour towards the person with the illness, and results in the
knock on effect of increased interpersonal stress which can only exacerbate the
symptoms of the 'Broken Mind'.
If we break our leg, we put the
utmost care into protecting it. We talk with empathy and treat the person suffering
with compassion. We put a rigid cast on the injury site. We provide crutches to
allow the person to support their leg whilst walking, or a wheel chair if
things are more complicated; and we all rally around to help, even wanting to
push the wheelchair.
However, with a fracture or a
break in the mind, we act as though the mind does not require this protection.
It's uncomfortable for us so we say- get a grip, pull yourself together, your
just behaving badly. We are full of negative clichés. Yet, trust me, I know
from experience that a person CANNOT just do these things without the
'appropriate' support and time.
With mental illness a 'glitch'
has occurred in the brain's development or programming; or neurones are not
communicating as and when they should. It is probably short term, but it WILL
be longer term without the appropriate Stress free help; but this will likely
develop into a permanent illness for many if we stay on the road we are on. Would you wash a burn site with hot water?
No,; likewise you should not add stress to a broken mind.
My own family have suffered
greatly due to mental illness and we are still affected many years on. When a member of your family is in a hospital
away from home and you have to travel far to see them, it impacts greatly on
the family all in areas such as emotion and finance.
Mental illness impacts on the
economy, with time taken off work and adds extra pressure on Health Services
and staff. Proper mental health care
will have financial benefit across the national economy, including maximised
productivity in the individual’s workplace.
As is the need of all, give these
women all that they need to recover close to their homes, and the costs will be
as low as it is possible to be. Holistic
and appropriate care should be the Government and Trust values, not back room
cuts and decisions for financial, not caring reasons.
Remember, it may be your Mother,
Wife or Sister who has a sudden breakdown soon.
For those of you who don't twitter - Our take on the response from Lancashire Care
The Beds in the Orchard Campaign received its first official response from the Trust this afternoon via our Twitter account @OrchardBeds from @LancashireCare.
Here's what they had to say and, of course, our response.
@OrchardBeds The decision to operate male only beds at The Orchard is a temporary measure and is under constant review. (1/5)
We can't argue about whether or not this is true as we only have this statement from the Trust about it. However; we do know that some Trust staff have been advised The Orchard may revert back to mixed provision once The Harbour opens in March 2015, suggesting that it is not under constant review as the decision has already been made. We are open to concede there may have been a communication problem if staff have not been informed about it remaining male only until the opening of The Harbour.
Regardless of whether this is temporary or not, it is impacting women and families now. It is hurting female service users now and there remains no clinical benefit to women from the closure.
@OrchardBeds There is a peak in demand for male beds & a reduction in demand for female beds - we have empty female beds at present. (2/5)
Two responses here. Firstly, it is likely that the peak in demand for male beds is linked to the trust closing a 15 bed male ward in Burnley and it is rather disingenuous to cite demand for male beds being the driving factor after closing 15 of them.
Secondly, the point about empty female beds is slightly misleading. The status of beds can change on an hourly basis. From personal experience a bed can be taken in the time it takes to have a consultation with your psychiatrist about whether you should go into hospital or not. A freedom of information request has already been submitted to the trust about how many women they've sent out of area in the last 4 years, often to private hospitals that should clarify demand.
We also directed them to this post - http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/10/is-based-on-need-self-fulfilling.html
This isn't about empty beds. Its about denying a whole group of service users access to local inpatient care solely based on their sex.
@OrchardBeds All Trust facilities have the ability to flex male/female beds in line with demand. (3/5)
This is indeed True. The Orchard had two 'swing' beds that could change between male and female. There were 10 fixed male beds and 6 fixed female beds. Up until recently, the two swing beds were female. The trust could have swung those beds to male, giving them 12 male and 6 female beds at The Orchard. Instead they decided to deny access to a whole group of service users from a wide area.
It is rather disappointing that the Trust sees removing access to local inpatient care to all women in the Lancaster area as 'flexing'.
@OrchardBeds The Orchard will revert to mixed sex as soon as this is clinically appropriate. (4/5)
There's nothing we can really say about this other than, how is it clinically appropriate to deny women access to local inpatient care. No, seriously. Our twitter handler has replied that we will be happy to discuss this with someone qualified to explain the clinical benefits to women of sending them out of the area for treatment.
@OrchardBeds We would be happy to discuss this further with you and you can contact us on communications@lancashirecare.nhs.uk (5/5)
One of our team had already emailed the complaints department with the letter we published here
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/not-sure-what-to-write-when-you-complain.html
We will publish their response as soon as they receive it.
Here's what they had to say and, of course, our response.
@OrchardBeds The decision to operate male only beds at The Orchard is a temporary measure and is under constant review. (1/5)
We can't argue about whether or not this is true as we only have this statement from the Trust about it. However; we do know that some Trust staff have been advised The Orchard may revert back to mixed provision once The Harbour opens in March 2015, suggesting that it is not under constant review as the decision has already been made. We are open to concede there may have been a communication problem if staff have not been informed about it remaining male only until the opening of The Harbour.
Regardless of whether this is temporary or not, it is impacting women and families now. It is hurting female service users now and there remains no clinical benefit to women from the closure.
@OrchardBeds There is a peak in demand for male beds & a reduction in demand for female beds - we have empty female beds at present. (2/5)
Two responses here. Firstly, it is likely that the peak in demand for male beds is linked to the trust closing a 15 bed male ward in Burnley and it is rather disingenuous to cite demand for male beds being the driving factor after closing 15 of them.
Secondly, the point about empty female beds is slightly misleading. The status of beds can change on an hourly basis. From personal experience a bed can be taken in the time it takes to have a consultation with your psychiatrist about whether you should go into hospital or not. A freedom of information request has already been submitted to the trust about how many women they've sent out of area in the last 4 years, often to private hospitals that should clarify demand.
We also directed them to this post - http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/10/is-based-on-need-self-fulfilling.html
This isn't about empty beds. Its about denying a whole group of service users access to local inpatient care solely based on their sex.
@OrchardBeds All Trust facilities have the ability to flex male/female beds in line with demand. (3/5)
This is indeed True. The Orchard had two 'swing' beds that could change between male and female. There were 10 fixed male beds and 6 fixed female beds. Up until recently, the two swing beds were female. The trust could have swung those beds to male, giving them 12 male and 6 female beds at The Orchard. Instead they decided to deny access to a whole group of service users from a wide area.
It is rather disappointing that the Trust sees removing access to local inpatient care to all women in the Lancaster area as 'flexing'.
@OrchardBeds The Orchard will revert to mixed sex as soon as this is clinically appropriate. (4/5)
There's nothing we can really say about this other than, how is it clinically appropriate to deny women access to local inpatient care. No, seriously. Our twitter handler has replied that we will be happy to discuss this with someone qualified to explain the clinical benefits to women of sending them out of the area for treatment.
@OrchardBeds We would be happy to discuss this further with you and you can contact us on communications@lancashirecare.nhs.uk (5/5)
One of our team had already emailed the complaints department with the letter we published here
http://bedsintheorchard.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/not-sure-what-to-write-when-you-complain.html
We will publish their response as soon as they receive it.
There's no trusting the Trust
A Source at the Lancashire Care NHS Trust today said that closing The Orchard to women is a 'temporary measure' until the new hospital "The Harbour" is opened in Blackpool.
This is a step away from the previous reasons of protecting the vulnerable, but could cover their reason of it being 'based on need'.
So why do they need more male beds now?
Following further enquires and investigation, we discovered that just weeks before The Orchard was closed to women, they closed Ward 18, a 15 bed male psychiatric ward in Burnley, with no means to cater for the number of beds they knew they needed.
If the Trust closes male beds, they should mitigate that closure by providing treatment in the community to the men they otherwise should have admitted as inpatients. Instead, they withdrew inpatient care to women of a large area of the trust. This is not acceptable.
It's the women of North Lancashire who are paying for this cost saving exercise. It is the women of North Lancashire who are being denied local treatment and its their families who are paying the cost in time, travel and disruption for this decision.
Lancashire Care is failing in its duty of care to the women it is meant to treat and support.
It has to change.
This is a step away from the previous reasons of protecting the vulnerable, but could cover their reason of it being 'based on need'.
So why do they need more male beds now?
Following further enquires and investigation, we discovered that just weeks before The Orchard was closed to women, they closed Ward 18, a 15 bed male psychiatric ward in Burnley, with no means to cater for the number of beds they knew they needed.
If the Trust closes male beds, they should mitigate that closure by providing treatment in the community to the men they otherwise should have admitted as inpatients. Instead, they withdrew inpatient care to women of a large area of the trust. This is not acceptable.
It's the women of North Lancashire who are paying for this cost saving exercise. It is the women of North Lancashire who are being denied local treatment and its their families who are paying the cost in time, travel and disruption for this decision.
Lancashire Care is failing in its duty of care to the women it is meant to treat and support.
It has to change.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)